Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

karma?

opiumpoetryopiumpoetry Delaware, Ohio, USA Explorer

Many Buddhists view karma as "if something bad happens to someone, it's because of their bad karma from this or a previous life." I now realize that such a belief is heartless and cruel. That is why I recently renounced Buddhism and now follow the teachings of Jesus.

Comments

  • marcitkomarcitko Veteran
    edited March 2023

    A few thoughts from my limited perspective:

    1) Good for you! Following your heart, mind and intuition sounds like a good idea. Find solace and happiness where you can. Is there a better option?

    2) Is it heartless and cruel that sometimes a star goes supernova and "dies"? That is it's "karma" based on the natural laws of physics. Similarly, we humans are subject to the same laws of cause and effect, the natural laws of physics as the star, but also less observable and to us less clear ones, such as emotional, moral, physical etc. Causes still produce effects, even if we're not always aware of them. It's good to keep an eye out and try to produce as many positive causes as possible and as few negative ones as possible.

    3) I have no recollection of past lives so have no opinion on past-life karma. But I do have recollection of previous "phases" of my life and can very well see both the positive and negative outcomes of some of my actions. That's my understanding of "past-life-karma".

    4) Thus have I read, in the final analysis/seeing, even karma is seen through so it is not some kind of ultimate truth or exact science.

    lobsterShoshin1opiumpoetryFleaMarket
  • FosdickFosdick in its eye are mirrored far off mountains Alaska, USA Veteran
    edited March 2023

    “Be not deceived, God is not mocked: for whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap.” Galatians 6:7.

    Karma is also acknowledged in Christianity, they just haven't given it a name, elaborated much in the way of teachings about it, or extended it to cover multiple lifetimes. I suspect it is pretty much a universally acknowledged principle in other religions, and in societies in general.

    To regard Karma as being "good" or "bad" I think tends to be an unfortunate and unnecessarily dualistic. oversimplification. Whatever we do now will most certainly affect our lives and our minds in the future - that's inescapable. Will that effect accord with our desires and what we imagine to be our needs, or trash our desires and show us something else, something previously undreamed of? It is fascinating to watch it unfold, like the Lotus blooming. Is the Lotus ugly, or beautiful? It depends on how we have constructed it, and also upon the way we choose to view it.

    marcitkoopiumpoetry
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator

    @opiumpoetry said:
    Many Buddhists view karma as "if something bad happens to someone, it's because of their bad karma from this or a previous life." I now realize that such a belief is heartless and cruel. That is why I recently renounced Buddhism and now follow the teachings of Jesus.

    Personally, I feel it's a great shame that you have chosen to evaluate a Philosophical Religion that came about 500 years or so before Christ's birth, and have dismissed its entire history, interpretations, mass of teachings, and meanings, for the fault of one misquoted and misunderstood view.
    For my part, having been brought up as a Roman Catholic for the best part of 45 years of my life, and having been educated thus-wise, I have embraced Buddhism wholeheartedly - not always as a good Buddhist, mind! - but I continue to appreciate much of what the New testament teaches and illustrates, and find much of its content worthy, and valid.

    Who was it said. "Judge not, that ye be not judged"....? ;)

    howlobsteropiumpoetry
  • FosdickFosdick in its eye are mirrored far off mountains Alaska, USA Veteran

    Karma is an issue of cause and effect, not of reward and punishment, carrot and stick, though some appear to interpret it in that way.

    If we look for cruelty in these realms, we need look no further than the Christian doctrine of original sin, whereby we are all cursed by the supposed transgression of Adam.

    Jesus himself, of course, had little to say about the issue. Matthew 5:22 perhaps?

    But I tell you that anyone who is angry with his brother will be subject to judgment. Again, anyone who says to his brother, 'Raca,' will be subject to the Sanhedrin . But anyone who says, 'You fool!' will be subject to the fire of hell.>

    opiumpoetry
  • "if something bad happens to someone, it's because of their bad karma from this or a previous life."

    Zen master Shakespeare once said

    “There is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so”

    This also applies to karma and how one perceives the results of one's actions,,,.Bearing in mind good and bad are relative

    Pyrrhonism holds that good and evil do not exist by nature, meaning that good and evil do not exist within the things themselves. All judgments of good and evil are relative to the one doing the judging.

    opiumpoetry
  • personperson Don't believe everything you think The liminal space Veteran

    The explanation that changed my mind on the subject from someone who did believe in karma as all encompassing was that just because someone's current suffering came about from past actions doesn't mean they aren't worthy of compassion and help. Helping them would also be their karma.

    I think I'd also ask if there isn't something else at work here? Most people wouldn't think that one idea is morally bankrupt and abandon the whole project. Are there other factors that led you to believe the way you do now and subsequent to that you now look on Buddhism with an unfavorable lens?

    Fosdickopiumpoetry
  • marcitkomarcitko Veteran
    edited March 2023

    Post deleted by author. :)

    Jeroenlobster
  • JeroenJeroen Luminous beings are we, not this crude matter Netherlands Veteran

    Post never written by author. ;)

    marcitko
  • opiumpoetryopiumpoetry Delaware, Ohio, USA Explorer

    @Fosdick said:
    Karma is an issue of cause and effect, not of reward and punishment, carrot and stick, though some appear to interpret it in that way.

    If we look for cruelty in these realms, we need look no further than the Christian doctrine of original sin, whereby we are all cursed by the supposed transgression of Adam.

    Jesus himself, of course, had little to say about the issue. Matthew 5:22 perhaps?

    But I tell you that anyone who is angry with his brother will be subject to judgment. Again, anyone who says to his brother, 'Raca,' will be subject to the Sanhedrin . But anyone who says, 'You fool!' will be subject to the fire of hell.>

    Original sin comes from the Old Testament. I, for one, think that being as the Old Testament is the OPPOSITE of the teachings of Jesus, it should be banished from the Christian Bible, along with the Gospel of Matthew.

    Fosdick
  • opiumpoetryopiumpoetry Delaware, Ohio, USA Explorer

    Thank you to everyone for your comments. I see the tone of my post has provoked some truly inspiring replies. I'm not sure I meant for my original post to sound as negative as I now realize it does. Perhaps "renounced" was the wrong word, a word used when I was caught up in the moment (as I too often am.) Maybe I meant to say that my newfound faith in Jesus has superseded my old beliefs, though even that may be too strong a word.

    I realize that everything gets corrupted over time. Too many Buddhists, especially Theravada, believe that people suffer due to their karma and so nothing can be done. I have heard exactly this viewpoint said aloud by many Buddhists in Indochina. To say that this is a corruption of the Buddha's original teachings is an understatement.

    Your replies have sparked some deeper thinking in my mind, deeper than I'm used to in this world, it being what it is. The 5 Precepts are principles that I believe everyone should follow, regardless of what else they believe. And let's remember that many insist that Jesus was himself a Buddhist monk in India during his 21 "lost years," an idea supported by the fact that so many of Jesus' words seem to be almost exact quotes from the Buddha. Funny how a few posts to a forum can help bring someone closer to enlightenment, but I feel these few posts have done exactly that for myself. I guess we all need to keep helping each other reach that hoped-for place.

    Thank you again for all your replies. =)

    marcitkolobster
  • opiumpoetryopiumpoetry Delaware, Ohio, USA Explorer

    I'm also sorry if my original post upset anyone. I guess you're never too old to learn the importance of considering the possible effects of your words before you post/speak them. Thank you to everyone again.

    lobsterKotishka
  • opiumpoetryopiumpoetry Delaware, Ohio, USA Explorer

    @person said:
    The explanation that changed my mind on the subject from someone who did believe in karma as all encompassing was that just because someone's current suffering came about from past actions doesn't mean they aren't worthy of compassion and help. Helping them would also be their karma.

    I think I'd also ask if there isn't something else at work here? Most people wouldn't think that one idea is morally bankrupt and abandon the whole project. Are there other factors that led you to believe the way you do now and subsequent to that you now look on Buddhism with an unfavorable lens?

    Perhaps I was considering how unfortunate I and my mother have been, the mistreatment we have always suffered at the hands of close family. I think it will take me many years to overcome my anger and learn to think calmly and more rationally.

    "Helping them would also be their karma." I'm reminded of a man in Cambodia who said of girls working in brothels, "It's the result of their past karma. There's nothing anyone can do." The reply is, if you don't try to help them then you are gaining bad karma for yourself. It's sad that anyone would misinterpret the dharma in that way.

    I guess we're all still on the journey, making giant leaps over the years but only baby steps day by day.

    personlobster
  • opiumpoetryopiumpoetry Delaware, Ohio, USA Explorer

    @Fosdick said:
    Karma is an issue of cause and effect, not of reward and punishment, carrot and stick, though some appear to interpret it in that way.

    If we look for cruelty in these realms, we need look no further than the Christian doctrine of original sin, whereby we are all cursed by the supposed transgression of Adam.

    Jesus himself, of course, had little to say about the issue. Matthew 5:22 perhaps?

    But I tell you that anyone who is angry with his brother will be subject to judgment. Again, anyone who says to his brother, 'Raca,' will be subject to the Sanhedrin . But anyone who says, 'You fool!' will be subject to the fire of hell.>

    You are absolutely correct. No one faith knows it all, not one is perfect. I think it's all one huge jigsaw puzzle and each faith is a only a few pieces of the puzzle. Thanks for your insight.

    Fosdick
  • JeroenJeroen Luminous beings are we, not this crude matter Netherlands Veteran

    @opiumpoetry said:
    No one faith knows it all, not one is perfect. I think it's all one huge jigsaw puzzle and each faith is a only a few pieces of the puzzle.

    Well, as the Dalai Lama said, “Don’t become a buddhist, but use buddhism to become a better whatever-you-are.” I think he was quite right to say that the insights of buddhist philosophy have something to offer to Christians, Muslims and others, and that some people are better off with other traditions. It is a personal choice.

    I would say that any spiritual path can be a good one. If it is approached with wisdom, care, insight, and openness there will be opportunities to get to know oneself and the universe, and there are certain universal aspects of the human experience which we get to recognise, such as silence and illusion.

    personopiumpoetry
  • AboudAboud Space New
    edited March 2023

    @opiumpoetry said:
    I'm reminded of a man in Cambodia who said of girls working in brothels, "It's the result of their past karma. There's nothing anyone can do."

    Hello. This is not the original Buddha teachings of kamma. I read the original Buddha teaching is if you believe your situation is due to past lives, your belief leads to inaction, which is wrong. Here it is, here

    "Having approached the brahmans & contemplatives who hold that... whatever a person experiences... is all caused by what was done in the past,' I said to them: 'Is it true that you hold that... whatever a person experiences... is all caused by what was done in the past?' Thus asked by me, they admitted, 'Yes.' Then I said to them, 'Then in that case, a person is a killer of living beings because of what was done in the past. A person is a thief... unchaste... a liar... a divisive speaker... an abusive speaker... an idle chatterer... covetous... malevolent... a holder of wrong views because of what was done in the past.' When one falls back on what was done in the past as being essential, monks, there is no desire, no effort [at the thought], 'This should be done. This shouldn't be done.' When one can't pin down as a truth or reality what should & shouldn't be done, one dwells bewildered & unprotected. One cannot righteously refer to oneself as a contemplative...

    https://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/study/kamma.html

    Fosdicklobsteropiumpoetry
  • @opiumpoetry said:
    I'm also sorry if my original post upset anyone. I guess you're never too old to learn the importance of considering the possible effects of your words before you post/speak them. Thank you to everyone again.

    I was so offended! :mrgreen:

    May have to go to Cambodia and sell myself to the highest bidder/Buddhist contemplative or sushi stall ...

    Pray for me! I have been barbecued! <3

    opiumpoetry
  • opiumpoetryopiumpoetry Delaware, Ohio, USA Explorer

    @lobster said:
    Pray for me! I have been barbecued! <3

    To be honest, I've felt that way my entire life. Seriously. I guess that's why I'm looking for refuge now, perhaps always will. On a lighter note, I'll look for you at the nearest sushi stall. ;)

    Shoshin1lobsterKotishka
Sign In or Register to comment.