Check out BuddhismIS.com. I think you will see an example of what happens when there is no moderation. People monopolize threads until it is unbearable. Then every one leaves. My take. Could be wrong.
topics left open do several things: go horrendously off-topic. end up with just two members bickering back and forth, lead to idle chatter, reckless speech and go round and round in circles with people just trying to get the better of each other, often through trolling or flaming.
Topic are closed for good reason. you may not be privy to that reason, unless you're the reason, or have anything to do with it.
I have closed topics recently (as you have obviously noted, @Iktomi,) with good reason. And have received PMs from others thanking me for it.
Any further questions, feel free to PM a Mod, or the Mod in question.
Comments
and people will continue to comment?
go horrendously off-topic.
end up with just two members bickering back and forth,
lead to idle chatter, reckless speech
and go round and round in circles with people just trying to get the better of each other, often through trolling or flaming.
Topic are closed for good reason.
you may not be privy to that reason, unless you're the reason, or have anything to do with it.
I have closed topics recently (as you have obviously noted, @Iktomi,) with good reason. And have received PMs from others thanking me for it.
Any further questions, feel free to PM a Mod, or the Mod in question.