Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

Past Lives = Ancestors?

mugzymugzy Veteran
edited July 2011 in Philosophy
We are all the continuation of our ancestors. Could this be a way of viewing our "past lives"?

I have been turning this idea over in my mind for many years now, and I still don't know quite how to explain it. I have always felt a deep connection to my ancestors, especially as a mixed-race person of Native American descent. I think of my parents, grandparents, and other close blood relatives and think of how I am a combination of their DNA. I see into our history, the millions of people leading up to now, those who died long ago but their genetic material continued on, creating new life and new consciousness. It makes me wonder if our ancestors and the knowledge of our history would influence the idea of reincarnation.

If we don't have children, what does that mean for our future lives?

Comments

  • upekkaupekka Veteran


    I have been turning this idea over in my mind for many years now,
    me too

    it is for sure

    but still not sure about how the exact relationship works

    still working on it
  • I agree that there may be some connection of the sort you suggest, but the way you pose the idea is not clear to me. Are you suggestion that something having to do with consciousness takes place in this process?

    The idea of rebirth in Buddhism comes from the other side of the planet, from people who are not genetically related to Native Americans.

    My ancestors were all Irish Catholic, and one known ancestor was actually (supposedly, you know how the Irish are about inflating stories) converted to Catholicism by St. Patrick himself. This would plant the idea of life after death according to Catholicism in my subconscious.

    Then again, when my son was about 12, he had been looking at some pictures of the exact area that my Irish ancestors lived, and some pictures of Tibet. Once he just sort of off-handedly asked me "Dad, can we move to Ireland or Tibet?" and I was a little surprised by the question, so I very calmly asked him "Why do you ask that, Son?" and he said "Because it feels like home."

    Go figure.
  • And BTW, for a really good movie that kinda sorta has something to do with what you seem to be talking about, see "Thunderheart" with Val Kilmer, Graham Greene, and Sam Shepherd. I do not support P2P downloading of movies or anything else.
  • auraaura Veteran

    The idea of rebirth in Buddhism comes from the other side of the planet, from people who are not genetically related to Native Americans.
    You have never heard of the voyages of Zheng He and the fact that in the late 1800's it was discovered that the Apache language was a dialect of Tartar Chinese? To wit:
    “… The Tartar Chinese speak the dialect of the Apaches. The Apaches bear a striking resemblance to the Tartar. In about the year 1885, W. B. Horton, who had served as County Superintendent of Schools, at Tucson, was appointed Post Trader at Camp Apache, and went to San Francisco to purchase his stock, where he hired a Chinese cook. His kitchen adjoined his sleeping apartment, and one evening while in his room he heard in the kitchen some Indians talking. Wondering what they were doing there at that hour of the night, he opened the door and found his cook conversing with an Apache. He asked his cook where he had acquired the Indian language. The cook said: “He speak all same me. I Tartar Chinese; he speak same me, little different, not much.” At Williams, in Navajo County, is another Tartar Chinaman, Gee Jim, who converses freely with the Apaches in his native language. From these facts it would seem that the Apache is of Tartar origin. From the fact that the Apache language was practically the same as that of the Tartar Chinese, colour is given to the theory advanced by Bancroft in his “Native Races,” Volume 5, p. 33, et seq., that Western America was “originally peopled by the Chinese, or, at least, that the greater part of the new world civilization may be attributed to these people…”
    Reference Source: The University of Arizona Library "Books of the South West" Chapter 1, Indians of Arizona:
    http://southwest.library.arizona.edu/hav7/body.1_div.1.html

    As for the idea of rebirth, evidence of rebirth is recognized all over the world by those who attend closely to very young children and do not shun and silence them, as many of them speak of having formerly been adults with definite issues just as soon as they are able to speak intelligibly at all.

  • aura, a good friend of mine - a Tibetan lama - insists that Mongols and Tibetans are related to Native Americans via the Siberian/Alaska frozen land bridge migrations. He only cites similarities in appearance and spiritual practices as his evidence. But we have also discussed cellular mitochondrial similarities that have been observed in some research. Obviously - peoples who migrated to North America over 10,000 years ago weren't carrying the Dharma - or were they?.........
  • The original Buddhists were not Mongols. I feel this conversation stretching quite a bit. Mongols did not become Buddhists until about 800 CE.

    Please don't let this become yet another rebirth thread.

    And the OP was unclear about the OP question and has not been back to clarify. This thread could go all over the place.
  • one of my past lives was as an ancestor... but this is mostly intuition, something to investigate later on (it was not as clear as the immediate past life).
  • OP has a very good question...is about the chicken & egg issues. The Shurangama Sutra provides you with detailed discourse with satisfying answer :wave:
  • aMattaMatt Veteran
    Mugzy, yes of course. Though be certain not to eternalize a self, its not like mugzy was his great great grand parent, but all of that is with you here and now. :)
  • vinlynvinlyn Colorado...for now Veteran
    How would that work since our life and our ancestors lives sometimes overlap?
  • auraaura Veteran
    edited July 2011
    Obviously - peoples who migrated to North America over 10,000 years ago weren't carrying the Dharma - or were they?.........
    Zheng He's vogages were in the 15th century (Ming Dynasty). There is evidence he founded Chinese colonies on the North American continent which were later abandoned and absorbed into the native populations.
    The original Buddhists were not Mongols. I feel this conversation stretching quite a bit. Mongols did not become Buddhists until about 800 CE.
    Zheng He was not a Mongol either, but from Yunnan Province, in the service of the emperor, with a fleet assembled from resources from all over the empire.
  • mugzymugzy Veteran
    edited July 2011
    I now regret mentioning my heritage. It was not meant to be a part of the discussion. I only brought it up because honoring my ancestors is important to me, and has been a part of my pondering the meaning of our descent through human history.
  • Obviously - peoples who migrated to North America over 10,000 years ago weren't carrying the Dharma - or were they?.........
    Zheng He's vogages were in the 15th century (Ming Dynasty). There is evidence he founded Chinese colonies on the North American continent which were later abandoned and absorbed into the native populations.
    The original Buddhists were not Mongols. I feel this conversation stretching quite a bit. Mongols did not become Buddhists until about 800 CE.
    Zheng He was not a Mongol either, but from Yunnan Province, in the service of the emperor, with a fleet assembled from resources from all over the empire.
    Mugzy's OP somehow suggests that ancestral memories are possibly connected to reincarnation or past lives. However it may be with Orientals and Native Americans, there is no clear evidence that Native Americans believe(d) in past lives or reincarnation, or that they carried the actual "ancestral memories" of their ancestors. There are orally transmitted traditions, but I know of no Native American tribe that believe they actually perpetuated ancestral consciousness apart from these orally transmitted teachings. There is no evidence that Native Americans held any beliefs resembling Buddhadharma or reincarnation.

    There is no way to distinguish possible "ancestral memories" from memories acquired from oral traditions. That's all I'm trying to say. My ancestors were Christian, supposedly as far back as the first century CE. Therefore my ancestral memories would carry a belief in the Christian life-after-death scenario, yet here I am a Buddhist believing in reincarnation.

    So my answer to these rather interesting stories about the integration of Orientals into Native American populations is "whatever". There's no evidence of Native American populations carrying Buddhadharma or a belief in reincarnation/rebirth, or that they carry on a collective consciousness apart from their oral traditions. And in his OP, Mugzy even admits that this is not a fully formed idea on his part.

    So, as politely as I can state it, my answer is "whatever".

  • mugzymugzy Veteran
    Please don't let this become yet another rebirth thread.
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    edited July 2011
    I'm not interested in my ancestors whatsoever. Can't relate. I haven't met my ancestors. Not even aquaintences.
  • AmeliaAmelia Veteran
    mugzy, I have always wondered the same thing. Is having children and continuing the DNA the only way to "stay alive?" I don't expect to know the answer in this lifetime!
  • AmeliaAmelia Veteran
    As for my ancestors, I am deeply intrigued by them. The thought that from the very beginning of time, there has been a line of genetics leading all the way to "me" is very exhilarating!
  • AmeliaAmelia Veteran
    This is why I have great respect for my grandpa and great grandma, who are the two closest people I have on "the other side." If their individual consciousness exists in any way beyond this plane, I honor them for going through the door before me and preparing the way.
  • vinlynvinlyn Colorado...for now Veteran
    I'm not interested in my ancestors whatsoever. Can't relate. I haven't met my ancestors. Not even aquaintences.
    Interesting. That's pretty much my viewpoint, too. I know my ancestors came from Ireland and settled in Palmyra, New York, right when the Erie Canal was being dug there...so they were probably canal diggers who then turned to farming. But I just can't care much about it since they are people I never met.

  • @Amelia

    the dead ancestor as protector is a recurring idea... but I don't know in which tradition, if any, it originated.
  • mugzymugzy Veteran
    mugzy, I have always wondered the same thing. Is having children and continuing the DNA the only way to "stay alive?" I don't expect to know the answer in this lifetime!

    As for my ancestors, I am deeply intrigued by them. The thought that from the very beginning of time, there has been a line of genetics leading all the way to "me" is very exhilarating!

    This is why I have great respect for my grandpa and great grandma, who are the two closest people I have on "the other side." If their individual consciousness exists in any way beyond this plane, I honor them for going through the door before me and preparing the way.
    Thank you for sharing these thoughts. I think the same things, wondering what it means that we share our genetic material with our parents, grand parents, great grandparents, great great, great great great, and so on and so on....
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    The self is not: form, feeling, perception, formation, nor consciousness.
  • mugzymugzy Veteran
    edited July 2011
    I agree that there may be some connection of the sort you suggest, but the way you pose the idea is not clear to me. Are you suggestion that something having to do with consciousness takes place in this process?
    @SherabDorje In my mind it's not even the level of consciousness, but perhaps more the sharing of physical form, life energy, reproduction... we're not clones of our ancestors, but do share genes that have been passed on by them over thousands or millions of years. (Or who knows how far back we could theoretically go?) We share physical features, personality traits, even up to having similar mental problems that run in the family. It just makes me wonder if my life is a kind of new life for them, or their lives are a part of what could be considered my "past life" experience. I don't know if that makes sense. Like I mentioned it's not a complete thought, just an idea that I've contemplated for many years.
  • <
    It just makes me wonder if my life is a kind of new life for them, or their lives are a part of what could be considered my "past life" experience.
    I've never heard of that in Buddhism or anywhere else. The rest of what you say is pretty much factual, or metaphorical in the sense of "our ancestors live on in us." Other that metaphor or the facts of DNA, I don't think I can agree with your basic premise, although I understand it's just something you've contemplated.

    Be well.
  • mugzymugzy Veteran
    I've never heard of that in Buddhism or anywhere else. The rest of what you say is pretty much factual, or metaphorical in the sense of "our ancestors live on in us." Other that metaphor or the facts of DNA, I don't think I can agree with your basic premise, although I understand it's just something you've contemplated.
    Yes it is probably something I will be contemplating for the rest of my life, or at least until I gain some insight into the matter! It's very hard to explain, since it's not a lot of cogent thoughts, but thanks for taking the time to provide your input.
  • of my parents, grandparents, and other close blood relatives and think of how I am a combination of their DNA. I see into our history, the millions of people leading up to now, those who died long ago but their genetic material continued on, creating new life and new consciousness.
    I have thought the same thing a long time ago. What would have happened if my grandfather on my father's side did not pass away when he was young. He would have probably grown up more happy and would have been less abusive. Then I thought that maybe it was my father's karma that it happened. Then I thought maybe it was my karma. Upon not being able to decide whose karma is whose, I realize that it could probably be a well mixed combination of everything. Then the thought of ending this chain came to mind, as in giving up my life to practice, but I made the choice to consider it when the time is right.

  • upekkaupekka Veteran
    edited July 2011
    what i suggest is 'i might be 'my' great or great, great or great, great, great grandma or grandpa'
    because
    i didn't know that 'the self is not: foam, feeling, perception,formation nor consciousness'

    if i knew it and i was aware of it at my last breath 'i wouldn't be here'
  • AmeliaAmelia Veteran
    @Amelia

    the dead ancestor as protector is a recurring idea... but I don't know in which tradition, if any, it originated.
    I am not thinking that they are my protectors. I don't know if they could ever intervene in my life. I am mostly having respect for whatever experiences they may have gained, having lived and died. They come up in dreams a lot with very interesting gestures and expressions. The have a most expressive silence. Sometimes I wonder if they really do exist and are are amplified by my memories of them. This is, as always, speculation.
  • auraaura Veteran
    "Past lives" are layers of a pandimensional entity that mark the growth and development of the consciousness of that entity, rather like tree rings mark the growth and development of a tree. A human being, or a tree, is not a narrow "self" consisting of any single one of its growth rings, but is a massive electromagnetic pattern beyond and including all of them.
    At least that is my observation and experience.
    It is also my observation and experience that a child exists as a clearly differentiated, observable, and separate electromagnetic pattern, before it is ever conceived, and that conception merely acts as a conduit through which it protrudes/manifests its desired growth pattern into this dimension.
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    Is my right arm the same life as my left arm?
  • auraaura Veteran
    edited July 2011
    Are they both functional in your world for you or has one of them been amputated and is giving you phantom pain?
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    They are both sensitivity. To say that they are mine is a notion.
  • cazcaz Veteran United Kingdom Veteran
    Someones been playing assassins creed...:)
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    no but I want to :D
  • mugzymugzy Veteran
    edited July 2011
    @caz namyaw I love those games :thumbsup:
  • cazcaz Veteran United Kingdom Veteran
    @caz namyaw I love those games :thumbsup:
    They are good Im looking forward to the next and hopefully last chapter of this saga ;)
Sign In or Register to comment.