Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

Caffeine and Meditation

tmottestmottes Veteran
edited August 2011 in Meditation
How about another one of these threads? haha. :p

I have noticed that caffeine, and in particular coffee, has a very detrimental effect on my mind and body. I find my mind racing through thoughts much faster than in a 'sober' state. I sweat profusely. I get really shaky. I can deal with the physical effects, but the mind racing is out of control. I notice the effects when I drink anything with caffeine (soda, energy drinks, coffee, tea, etc), but they don't become a distraction until about regular coffee caffeine levels (decaf to a much lesser degree).

With that in mind I have stopped drinking coffee, soda, and energy drinks. I still consume teas, but only after eating something first. This seems to work the best for me. I was curious if other people found caffeine, coffee in particular, to be a 'intoxicant' for mindfulness or meditation? If you don't think that it does, is there the possibility that you are just not aware of its 'intoxicating' effects? Obviously we are all different and this might just be me, but I was curious on your opinions/experiences.

Comments

  • How about another one of these threads? haha. :p

    I have noticed that caffeine, and in particular coffee, has a very detrimental effect on my mind and body. I find my mind racing through thoughts much faster than in a 'sober' state. I sweat profusely. I get really shaky. I can deal with the physical effects, but the mind racing is out of control. I notice the effects when I drink anything with caffeine (soda, energy drinks, coffee, tea, etc), but they don't become a distraction until about regular coffee caffeine levels (decaf to a much lesser degree).

    With that in mind I have stopped drinking coffee, soda, and energy drinks. I still consume teas, but only after eating something first. This seems to work the best for me. I was curious if other people found caffeine, coffee in particular, to be a 'intoxicant' for mindfulness or meditation? If you don't think that it does, is there the possibility that you are just not aware of its 'intoxicating' effects? Obviously we are all different and this might just be me, but I was curious on your opinions/experiences.
    There are little to no such effects for me when I drink coffee, but I imagine that if there were I would quit drinking it as well.

  • That's the point of the 5th precept, isn't it - to refrain from intoxicants that lead to heedlessness or lack of mindfulness.

    So for some people, caffeine would fall into this category - for others, maybe not.
  • Every human body will have its own reaction to any drug that's introduced into it, so you may just be particularly prone to the effects of caffeine. Others could drink five cups of espresso and not bat an eye. Also, your body will eventually become tolerant to the effects of many drugs, caffeine included. If you drank the same exact number of milligrams of caffeine each and every day, within a fairly short time, its effects on you would be noticeably less.

    That said, if it affects you like that, then don't consume it. If it affects your practice, definitely don't consume it.

    Having a good idea where this thread might be headed (if the other thread is any indication), let me just say right now that caffeine is, as far as I'm aware, not a regulated drug in any society or any country anywhere on earth. Marijuana is. There's a good reason for that.
  • edited August 2011
    How about another one of these threads? haha. :p

    I have noticed that caffeine, and in particular coffee, has a very detrimental effect on my mind and body. I find my mind racing through thoughts much faster than in a 'sober' state. I sweat profusely. I get really shaky. I can deal with the physical effects, but the mind racing is out of control. I notice the effects when I drink anything with caffeine (soda, energy drinks, coffee, tea, etc), but they don't become a distraction until about regular coffee caffeine levels (decaf to a much lesser degree).

    With that in mind I have stopped drinking coffee, soda, and energy drinks. I still consume teas, but only after eating something first. This seems to work the best for me. I was curious if other people found caffeine, coffee in particular, to be a 'intoxicant' for mindfulness or meditation? If you don't think that it does, is there the possibility that you are just not aware of its 'intoxicating' effects? Obviously we are all different and this might just be me, but I was curious on your opinions/experiences.
    There are little to no such effects for me when I drink coffee, but I imagine that if there were I would quit drinking it as well.

    Snap! coffee has no effect on me anyone so i do think it would if i were to stop!! i do have an issue with stop smoking, l am desperate to stop. I have just read Allen Carr Easy Way to give up smoking and it all seems like common sense. I dont want to use NRT so its just me and my mind on the path to not smoking. I have smoked for 20 years on and off and the other day i had a lay in bed (the kids at dads) so had not had a cig for over 12 hrs! wham i felt drunk l was so ashamed had anyone seen me outside smoking then staggering inside they would have thought l was drunk. I dont know what shocked me more that feeling, or the 1000's of cigs l have smoked and that feeling was not there but the cig still had such an effect on my brain! Need to stop!!!

  • tmottestmottes Veteran
    edited August 2011
    @Mountains I guess I still can't wrap my head around this whole intoxication thing. What exactly was the buddha referring to when he said majja? I like to follow the spirit of the law, but I am not sure I have enough historical context to do so. Does somebody have their own translation/interpolation of this precept? I think surā and meraya are pretty straightforward, but majja seems to be more vague. I am not trying to get out of this precept, just trying to best understand the meaning. I mean what other things do I eat that would be considered an intoxicant to others, but not to me?
    I undertake the training rule to abstain from fermented drink that causes heedlessness.
    Surāmerayamajjapamādaṭṭhānā veramaṇī sikkhāpadaṃ samādiyāmi.
    I don't drink coffee because it does effect my practice, but I am curious as to why there appears to be a relativity about what an intoxicant really is. If coffee harms my practice and it doesn't harm others', that implies that we each have our own intoxicants or it really does harm others' without their awareness. It seems wrong to say that one of the the 5 precepts are subjective or that any of them are.

    Is it possible that the precepts are closely tied to karma? Maybe, the 5 precepts take on a different meaning based on the karma we have/do generate? Sort of like Plato's perfect forms?

    @kayward2011 I don't smoke tobacco and when I have in the past, I feel "drunk" for a short period of time.
  • I don't know if it's just me, but it takes a large amount of caffeine to affect me. However, i have drank it excessively on an empty stomach, then went to take a Differential Equations exam. I literally spent the whole time staring at my paper while my mind raced recklessly... I did very poorly on that exam :l I recognize that it can affect me, but it typically doesn't. This may be due to my size: 6'4" and 230lbs.

    I can't comment on its effects in meditation. I'm receiving my cushion in the mail today. So my practice will have no excuse to be inconsistent
  • I should add that caffeine didn't always effect me as severely. I did have more tolerance for caffeine when I was younger, but I suppose I don't/didn't drink enough to keep up that tolerance.
  • auraaura Veteran
    edited August 2011
    The thing about drugs, all drugs, is that they contain significant toxins that are toxic to the body. That toxicity is how drugs work, disrupting homeostasis in the body in order to render their effect on the body.

    The thing about toxins, all toxins, is that the body tries to protect itself from them by isolating them in fat cells away from the rest of the body. The body can store toxins in fat cells fairly safely and pretty much indefinitely.
    Toxin load and storage is pretty much cumulative over time unless significant measures are undertaken to clear it.

    The thing about being female is that women have more fat cells in their bodies than men, (to provide for the possibility of pregnancy and lactation). It is also one of the reasons why women are far more easily and intensely chemically affected, and addicted, then are men.

    Depending on how much and how fast one metabolizes that fat and releases those toxins and fails to clear them through the liver and from the body, it is possible to overload the body with significant toxicity and to experience significant toxic symptoms. Hallucinogenic "flashbacks" long after last ingestion of a hallucinogen such as LSD are possible via this method. Sudden lead poisoning from the sudden release of a significant amount of toxic lead storage gradually accumulated over years of working around chemicals or alloys containing lead is possible via this method. Sudden toxic complications of pregnancy whenever pregnancy metabolizes fat storage and releases a flood of toxins contained therein is possible via this method.

    The thing about caffeine is that it increases fat metabolism.

  • 'The thing about caffeine is that it increases fat metabolism'

    NO please dont tell me this, l need to reduce caffine....

  • @Aura Are you suggesting that my reaction to caffeine is not due to caffeine itself, but chemicals that are released as a result of caffeine increasing fat metabolism (fatty acid oxidation)? Could you please explain how your post answers or sheds light on my questions?
  • When sitting, my only aim is to just sit. Nothing else. The rest is just listening or watching, like an idiot. There's no requirement for liquids anyway. Having to pee tends to defeat the purpose of being in the "empty box." M' thinks.
  • When sitting, my only aim is to just sit. Nothing else. The rest is just listening or watching, like an idiot. There's no requirement for liquids anyway. Having to pee tends to defeat the purpose of being in the "empty box." M' thinks.
  • @SimpleWitness I am not sure I understand the point you were trying to make. The OP is about discussing the effects that caffeine has on our bodies and consequently our buddhist practice. For some people it doesn't seem to affect their practice (or not that they are aware) and yet for me it does, drastically. I am looking to understand more about how caffeine really affects meditation as the drug does stay in your body longer than you are aware of its effects.
    Caffeine is fully absorbed by the digestive system in approximately 45 minutes, according to the Coffee Science Information website. Typically, the peak of concentration is 15 to 120 minutes after caffeine is consumed. Caffeine stays in the bodies of men for five to nine hours, but the amount of time is reduced by 30 to 50 percent in smokers. The length of stay for caffeine in women using oral contraceptives is approximately 12 to 15 hours, and can be as long as 15 hours in pregnant women as well, according to the Coffee Science Information Centre and the International Coffee Organization.
  • That's the point of the 5th precept, isn't it - to refrain from intoxicants that lead to heedlessness or lack of mindfulness.

    So for some people, caffeine would fall into this category - for others, maybe not.
    Not the same from 5th precept point of view. And if you would desire for extreme 5th precept on meditation based on your point of view, is dharani, probably only Buddha Sakyamuni. Intoxicants in 5th precept that will make one lost its sense in normal circumstances like liquor, esctasy etc that totally gain control of your conscious mind.
  • @tmottes

    It looks as if my post was finished, but it's not. There was more that was supposed be added, only, my phone is really acting screwy and hasn't been allowing me to edit my comments successfully. My apologies, tomottes.

    My comment was supposed to begin in reference to caffeine beverages and continue with some reading that the affects of caffeine is a natural diuretic, which increases the urge to urinate with the hypertension that caffeine can give. That tends to get in the way also. There was more, but it's been a while since my last comment.

    :P
  • @SimpleWitness haha ... I have had the same issues with my phone, so no worries. Yes, having to pee while meditating is sure annoying. When it happens to me, I have tried to shift focus to the feeling of needing to urinate. I don't last too long before I am in the bathroom.
  • auraaura Veteran
    .
    @Aura Are you suggesting that my reaction to caffeine is not due to caffeine itself, but chemicals that are released as a result of caffeine increasing fat metabolism (fatty acid oxidation)? Could you please explain how your post answers or sheds light on my questions?
    I'm agreeing with you that caffeine can indeed have strange and detrimental effects on mind, body, and meditation, and beyond even the direct stimulant effects of the caffeine itself, because of its ability to increase fat metabolism and release stored toxins therein.
    One can have all manner of toxins stored in the fat cells in one's body, from the lead in the paint one chewed as an infant to residual toxic chemicals from one's food, water, pharmaceuticals (prescribed or not), career, and environment.
    The combination of not having eaten and drinking coffee was what had apparently brought on the post LSD flashback of that guy in the middle of work, years after he had quit taking LSD. Apparently the same thing (fasting combined with caffeine) has been known to cause a sudden release of lead absorbed and stored by the body in the course of some occupations that can supposedly give a man a bout of high-circulating-lead-level-induced impotence, and in women toxins released in like manner can cause complications in pregnancy.
    My body can't deal with caffeine either. I don't know if it's entirely the caffeine itself or if it has also to do with the fact that as children we used to play in lead paint contaminated sand left over from sandblasting. It was more lead paint flecks than it was sand and it would have qualified as an extremely hazardous toxic waste dump.
  • auraaura Veteran
    I don't know if it's just me, but it takes a large amount of caffeine to affect me. However, i have drank it excessively on an empty stomach, then went to take a Differential Equations exam. I literally spent the whole time staring at my paper while my mind raced recklessly... I did very poorly on that exam :l I recognize that it can affect me, but it typically doesn't. This may be due to my size: 6'4" and 230lbs.
    Excessive caffeine, empty stomach.... strange unexpected effect, you see?
    It could just be the caffeine, or it could be that also something toxic may have been released from fat storage into the bloodstream...

    I never had a "racing mind" in college with no food and black tea before the calculus exam.... it was a heavy and dull feeling about the liver, like something had bloated or otherwise poisoned it.. ugh....
  • @tmottes

    Lol! Thanks for your understanding. This phone has been lagging lately.

    Yeah, that is so true! Who's to say otherwise? When you gotta go you gotta go! =-))

    It's usual for me to meditate each time before eating or drinking anything, and with the certainty that the body is clean and emptied from anything that may thwart the purpose. This isn't all of the time, however, the effort of cessation anything influential really helps before meditation. That way it is more likely that the body is prepared.

    Namaste

  • Thanks for this thread. I am feeling the same way as the OP when I drink Coffee before Meditating. Would try meditating without, I am coffee dependent and need it first thing in the morning, so I don't know if I can be fully awake to be aware during meditation but in the same vein, I don't want to feel my heart racing or be excitable when I am in a meditative state.
  • @FindingMyWay exercising in the morning is a way to wake up without coffee. You might find that you can cut back significantly on coffee consumption by just a quick 20 minutes jog around the block or some jumping jacks, pushups, etc.
Sign In or Register to comment.