Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

I think I've made a start to realising what Emptiness is...

ToshTosh Veteran
edited October 2010 in Buddhism Basics
I think I've made a start to realising what Emptiness is.

I've had trouble with understanding this Emptiness business, but this evening I think I may have started to realise what it actually is.

Here's some background first. I have a 14 year old daughter, with all the suffering that entails! But, for a few weeks now, when we interact together, I have been trying to imagine that she's my Mother from a previous life; and it's really been working and our relationship has greatly improved.

It makes me speak to her on a more human-to-human level, rather than from an authoritarian position of father to daughter.

I initially thought that this was because it deflates my ego when I speak to her; but a thought occurred to me that it could also be because when I imagine her to be my mother from a previous life, I am forgetting all about our previous history of stroppiness, bad behaviour, and cheekiness; i.e. I'm not labelling her in a negative way.

So, is this a start to the realisation of 'Emptiness'?

Comments

  • cazcaz Veteran United Kingdom Veteran
    edited October 2010
    Hi Tosh Emptiness is realizing objects and phenomena In general do not appear the way they exist, Studying Lamrim you find that it all ties in viewing sentient beings as our mothers helps overcome an appearance of them not being dear to us, and eventually viewing every sentient being as our spiritual guide and as a Buddha...It all ties in you begin to see that phenomena have no Inherant self but are only a mere imputation of mind, Its very clever. :)
  • edited October 2010
    I had major insight into emptiness after a certain experience with a certain drug. It's hard to explain.
  • edited October 2010
    I've been kinda getting emptiness the last day or 2. Awesome/crazy stuff
  • cazcaz Veteran United Kingdom Veteran
    edited October 2010
    I had major insight into emptiness after a certain experience with a certain drug. It's hard to explain.

    Drugs Increase Delusion. ;)
  • ravkesravkes Veteran
    edited October 2010
    Realizing emptiness is simply realizing the obvious.

    The impermanent nature of reality, your death.. your daughter's death.
    Everyone's substance is fleeting and essentially empty, whatever arises in this world is also empty and impermanent.. it's emotions, thoughts, images, sensations..
    All coming and going.. changing, never staying..

    When you accept this fully, you can treat your daughter with compassion. Realizing that what has happened yesterday has passed and is rotting away..

    Please let go of these concepts. Concentrate on what's actually happening. Go meditate and see all these things come and go for yourself, it's painfully simple.

    Come off the delusion, why imagine when all the answers are right in front of you.
    Accept the nature of reality and let go.
    It's time to stop beating around the bush.
  • edited October 2010
    caz namyaw wrote: »
    Drugs Increase Delusion. ;)
    That is a generalization based on assumption. I can see how it would seem true, and I agree it's true in most cases, but I know through direct experience the effects I experienced.

    I would think of some crazy concept, then I would want to tell it to my friends, so I'd start speaking, but in my mind I would have to go back to the concept in order to describe it, but upon going back to the concept, I just remember thinking "what?" because I was looking at the concept and trying to find its nature so I could describe it, and saw how it was empty, and i couldn't finish explaining. This is a very poor description of the experience but it's the best I could do with this english language. That was at the beginning of my trip. The whole rest of the day I said the word "nothing" dozens of times. I had koan experiences. I would ask myself "what?" which would then point to mind, and then "it's nothing!"
  • seeker242seeker242 Zen Florida, USA Veteran
    edited October 2010
    I realized emptiness after I skipped breakfast and lunch.
  • ThailandTomThailandTom Veteran
    edited October 2010
    I am actually going to go with questionful on this one. Yes many drugs do just create delusion, but certain substances such as Ayahuasca have been used to reach greatly profound insight for thousands of years. It is not about seeing pretty colours or laughing in a dribbling mess, people actually come away with great profound wisdom to which they may get from a long deep meditation stint.

    Check this link out http://www.brainwave-sync.com/page.html?id=10

    I am not making another post condemning all drug usage as right, I am fully aware of the precepts but this substance in particular is in my opinion a different matter entirely. I do not take any sibstances now and have not for a long period of time, they are for the most part destructive and a hindrance.
  • ChrysalidChrysalid Veteran
    edited October 2010
    I had a big flash of realisation a little while ago.

    At one time I considered myself a Gnostic Christian, and in one of the Gnostic texts Jesus says that the man who has found the world has found a corpse.
    I was looking out the window the other day when the truth of the saying hit me, phenomena are dead, the world is a corpse. Things aren't inhabited by life, at their core they are void.
  • cazcaz Veteran United Kingdom Veteran
    edited October 2010
    That is a generalization based on assumption. I can see how it would seem true, and I agree it's true in most cases, but I know through direct experience the effects I experienced.

    I would think of some crazy concept, then I would want to tell it to my friends, so I'd start speaking, but in my mind I would have to go back to the concept in order to describe it, but upon going back to the concept, I just remember thinking "what?" because I was looking at the concept and trying to find its nature so I could describe it, and saw how it was empty, and i couldn't finish explaining. This is a very poor description of the experience but it's the best I could do with this english language. That was at the beginning of my trip. The whole rest of the day I said the word "nothing" dozens of times. I had koan experiences. I would ask myself "what?" which would then point to mind, and then "it's nothing!"


    Correct It is an assumption, Putting Intoxicants into the system dont result in Natural clarity, It can in some cases result in Induced clairty like hallucination but now where near the bliss of actual insight and concentration, It is an obstruction in itself to make the mistake of thinking that Drugs that are well known for their Hallucinagenic qualities will produce anything other then Hallucinations, Realization and insight come through turning the mind Inwards Buddha never reconmended this approach as it is like getting lost In a Dream within a Dream where you struggle to tell the difference between what is a correct path and what May be similar to but not.
  • robotrobot Veteran
    edited October 2010
    Experience has told me that talking about this is a waste of time at best. Someone else started it so I'll add my story. In my early 20's I was picking and eating psilocybin mushrooms. I had several run of the mill trips at first. Up to that point in my life I had taken LSD many times and was accustomed to the flowery hallucinations that psychedelics usually produce. Then, when sitting alone in the forest contemplating nature and such, things changed. My vision cleared up to an incredible degree. There were no visual distortions. The world took on a type of integration I'll call it where what would normally seem chaotic in nature had a type of pattern that seemed to make sense. Self luminous is a phrase that RichardH used somewhere I think and that describes it. Mental images were intense and precise, not random crap. I was overwhelmed with joy. It was extremely emotional. This experience was repeated a number of times that fall, till the rain came and I had to move back indoors. In later experiences the bliss was still there but the emotions calmed down. I think that one of the reasons that things went the way that they did was that the fellow I was traveling with at the time was of a very spiritual bent and had been meditating for years already at that point. So I felt that I was learning new things with him and was expecting mysterious insights. Also I was into Carlos Casteneda at the time, though this was not like any of the experiences he described in "a Separate Reality. I had no idea what enlightenment meant except that I wanted it. I knew from the start that this was not enlightenment but it sure felt like it. I have never forgotten the intensity of the experiences and I can still glimpse that world occasionally. If anyone bothers to read this and can relate to it you would be the first one. I never take drugs now and don't recommend taking them for anyone else.-P
  • edited October 2010
    I can relate to that! The best experience of my life was on psilocybin, when I turned on a POWERFUL bliss lamp in my heart. it had a dimmer switch, not a toggle. I even experimented with turning it up really strong and dimming it off and seeing the effect it had on the people around me. trippy stuff.
    caz namyaw wrote:
    Drugs that are well known for their Hallucinagenic qualities will produce anything other then Hallucinations, Realization and insight come through turning the mind Inwards
    The drug is just molecules. They are not part of this discussion. what is being discussed is their effect. a COMPLETELY different thing. I don't think that these effects are "well known." I mean direct experience. Yes, there are many well-known ideas regarding them, but I tell you it is dangerous to go by these.
    What I have found through direct experience is that psilocybin temporarily increases certain facilities that are already present when we're sober. The same facilities that a meditator cultivates! They allow for extreme concentration on the present moment, and an extremely un-biased experience, because they somehow temporarily minimize the mind's conditioning. That's the best I can explain it. I will also say that in the four or five times I took psilocybin, and the one time i took LSD, not once did something that wasn't there appear in my vision, and nothing went wavy or changed shape or color.

    I don't do drugs anymore. But I don't like when people make claims about the direct experience that contradict what I have directly experienced.
  • robotrobot Veteran
    edited October 2010
    Questionful- Exactly. If someone has not experienced something how can they say how it is for the person who has? Like I said before talking about it usually isn't worth it. Glad you understand tho.
  • edited October 2010
    Personally I think psychedelics can be helpful in developing some ideas which it is possible to develop even without. Personally I think marijuana is a drug that doesn't alter your consciousness that much and can produce a lot of insight. Haven't smoked it in a while, but there's a solid chance i'm going to again when I get a job. Those of you who have done it(more than a couple times...like done it at least somewhat regularly) know it's not really a drug. Of course, by some definitions of drug it is, but almost any substance is a drug by some definition. It's not even comparable to other drugs.
  • robotrobot Veteran
    edited October 2010
    TheJourney-I think you are kidding yourself if you think that you can have a meditation practice and a pot habit at the same time. But you are only 19 and doing great so what the heck. I didn't stop smoking till I was 32 but I'm really thankful that my 20Yr old doesn't smoke pot. I tell him all the time that he is on the right track. He knows it.-P
  • edited October 2010
    I'm not sure if i'm going to start again or not. But it's always been something that has supplemented my life and not my life. I just think different on it, not in a bad way. I took the same test once sober once high and I got about 10% better when high. It doesn't make me stupid by any means, I stay in control and mindful. I just view things from a different perspective then when sober. I love the way I think when high. Like I said, I don't mean dumb by different. I feel it's a personal thing, based on how it affects you, but some see it in black and right and you're free to your opinion.
  • edited October 2010
    Dude it's definitely a drug. I was a stoner for one year, I am familiar with weed.

    Like you said I think it can be very helpful. But for me the dangerous part of it was that it leads to an addiction to stimulation. Which is not good. For meditation practice or life in general. I figured, smoking marijuana very infrequently would be a good compromise. But just like how fat people on diets never actually stick to their diets, I knew that I would not be able to keep my use down to a minimum. I used to love marijuana, it used to be my life, but now I am not going to do it ever. And I really do feel like I'm on the right track. You can feel it! It's freedom.
  • edited October 2010
    I believe it can be a problem for some people. Some people use it and they get stupid and act in less-than-mindful ways etc. When I contemplate high I have a ton of unbelievable realizations. I'm not saying I couldn't have gotten them sober, i'm just saying it would take longer. Honestly, this "high" feeling i've been getting since i've been getting into my practice is similar to what weed does to me. Except I don't hear my thoughts/music in my head as much :lol:
  • robotrobot Veteran
    edited October 2010
    TheJourney-You are preaching to the converted. Did I mention that I smoked till I was 32? I have had a constant stream of 19 to 25 yr olds on the boat with me for over thirty years. Dozens of them. Almost every one of them smoked pot. But none of them wanted to study Buddhism or seek enlightenment. You are different from them.I just don't think that meditation and pot use go hand in hand. I could be wrong.-P
  • edited October 2010
    Yea for me it's up to the individual. I haven't smoked since I started really getting into buddhism so i'm not 100% sure. If it interferes with my practice then my practice comes first.
  • ravkesravkes Veteran
    edited October 2010
    I tripped on LSD and damn near committed suicide.
    It ripped me from myself, forced me to confront reality as it was.. all my mind could do was define life as insane.. therefore suicidal thoughts, depression, panic attacks.. etc.. some of which continued after my trip.. which eventually led me to the Buddha Dharma and the nature of the mind..
    Enabled me to see how I created this reality thru words, and whilst meditating saw the impermanent nature of these things.. and how I really didn't know what life was..
    These drugs are dangerous.. LSD may lead you to come face to face with your delusion.. but it can also lead you down the illusory existential rabbit hole which leads to the loony bin if you aren't mindful .. (which isn't what you are on intoxicants).

    Therefore, take it easy.. you have time.
    It's been a year since my trip and subsequent panic attacks for a few months based on 'absurdity' of life.. and existential angst.. to finally see thru meditation what hell I've been creating for myself..

    The druggie 'enlightenment' 'bliss' blah blah path doesn't exist..
    Different states of bliss, love, happiness, sadness, depression, euphoria will come and go .. whichever state you attach to you will become.. (you become your thoughts essentially as they shape reality) as Buddha succinctly describes..

    It's all really testable.. but what if you accept that you know nothing.. you no longer believe in the interpretations of these thoughts, emotions, sensations, images.. just rest.
    Do absolutely nothing and let go.

    And so it goes.. Forget all the drugs, just be mindful :)
    Pretty soon it'll be effortless and you won't need anything or anybody to tell you what's up you'll naturally follow the path Buddha set out for us and see intuitively that everything is just as it is..

    Meditate and see for yourself. ;)
  • cazcaz Veteran United Kingdom Veteran
    edited October 2010
    5th Precept.

    Intoxicants lead to futher Delusion, If they where a source of true happiness you would be without problems now and the more you would have the more your happiness would increase...But we know this not to be true now dont we :)
  • NamelessRiverNamelessRiver Veteran
    edited October 2010
    I've had trouble with understanding this Emptiness business, but this evening I think I may have started to realise what it actually is.
    There is a good, down to earth, book about it called Introduction to Emptiness by Guy Newland. It is a must read :-)
  • ThailandTomThailandTom Veteran
    edited October 2010
    I read something by the dalai lama today which read something like, 'having a firm understanding on emptiness is not an entirely wise realisation, it can only really be used as a basis'. It read something along those lines. I was quite surprised as I was under some delusion that once somebody understood emptiness properly that they could integrate it into ones life and that would be that :p lol
  • ToshTosh Veteran
    edited October 2010
    Hi, thanks for the replies guys; I've put Emptiness to one side; though I'll still do the meditation on it.

    But, just to make you smile, here's what happened after a lesson on Emptiness at my local Buddhist centre:

    I was having a chat with a monk and I remarked that "I think being a Geordie (joking that Geordies are thick) is a bar to understanding Emptiness!"

    The monk replied, "Point to me where a Geordie is!"

    :confused:
  • ToshTosh Veteran
    edited October 2010
    There is a good, down to earth, book about it called Introduction to Emptiness by Guy Newland. It is a must read :-)

    I'll get it from Amazon; thanks.
  • ThailandTomThailandTom Veteran
    edited October 2010
    lol tosh, I never looked at where you are from boyo! I am from bristol originally :p a mere hop over the bridge.

    I think emptiness is one of the hardest concepts to understand in buddhism, but it is only one part of it remember. I personally like to start with compassion, leading a clean honest life and things that are pure and innocent such as this. Then work my way into the deeper concepts as I go. But good luck anyway :)
  • ToshTosh Veteran
    edited October 2010
    lol tosh, I never looked at where you are from boyo! I am from bristol originally :p a mere hop over the bridge:)

    What is Bristol? Take away the daft accents, is that still Bristol? Probably! :D

    Yes, Tom, I live in Chepstow and I'm a fairly frequent visitor to the Amitabh Centre on the Gloucester Road. I can see the bridge from where I'm sat!

    I hope it's warmer in Thailand than it is here!
  • ThailandTomThailandTom Veteran
    edited October 2010
    I thankfully spent 5 years in Bath so do not have a bristolian accent :) But yea, I do miss bristol sometimes, it has a great night life and mini culture going on there. But then at other times I really do not miss it.

    I see you have been influenced by your talk with the monk today, they have that affect on you lol. Today I have been trying to examine how things come into being due to causation and how they come to their cessation through the cause that brought them into being. All because I read a little of what a monk had written somewhere :P

    It is warmer in thailand yes, very much so. I have adapted to the heat though and seeing as the 'cool' season is approaching, I notice it. Last night I was laying outside under the stars at around 2am and it was nearly cool enough to want to put a t shirt back on. When I come home over xmas I am in for a shock I am sure :D
  • cazcaz Veteran United Kingdom Veteran
    edited October 2010
    Tosh wrote: »
    Hi, thanks for the replies guys; I've put Emptiness to one side; though I'll still do the meditation on it.

    But, just to make you smile, here's what happened after a lesson on Emptiness at my local Buddhist centre:

    I was having a chat with a monk and I remarked that "I think being a Geordie (joking that Geordies are thick) is a bar to understanding Emptiness!"

    The monk replied, "Point to me where a Geordie is!"

    :confused:


    Hehe Excellent :lol:
  • edited October 2010
    ravkes wrote: »
    The druggie 'enlightenment' 'bliss' blah blah path doesn't exist..
    Different states of bliss, love, happiness, sadness, depression, euphoria will come and go .. whichever state you attach to you will become.. (you become your thoughts essentially as they shape reality) as Buddha succinctly describes..

    It's all really testable.. but what if you accept that you know nothing.. you no longer believe in the interpretations of these thoughts, emotions, sensations, images.. just rest.
    Do absolutely nothing and let go.

    And so it goes.. Forget all the drugs, just be mindful :)
    I never said it was a path. I tried to clearly point out that it is not a path. I meant that they can be a step on the path, and if they are not abandoned after they have served their purpose, they will be a hinderance on the path. Also, I did not mean that the temporary emotional state was what was helpful about the drug (although I do believe it is possible to learn important lessons from temporary emotions); I meant that the ways our views are changed can be very helpful. Just like how meditation can help change our views in a very helpful way.
    And what you said about "do absolutely nothing and let go" I think is unrealistic. The Buddha himself taught the fourth noble truth. And he himself took 6 years. I think it takes a lot of gradual change to get to the goal. All I'm saying about drugs is that they can be a powerful tool to help us make this change. To be clear, I believe that after one has progressed to a certain level, drugs will not be much help anymore, and because of their problems, he should no longer use drugs. This certain level is around the beginning of the path too. But I believe that at that point in the path, they can be quite powerful, getting a lot of progress done in a short amount of time.
    caz namyaw wrote: »
    5th Precept.

    Intoxicants lead to futher Delusion, If they where a source of true happiness you would be without problems now and the more you would have the more your happiness would increase...But we know this not to be true now dont we :)

    I never said that drugs were a source of true happiness. We do indeed know that to be the case, so I am confused about why you said that. I hope you didn't misunderstand me. I will explain more.
    "Intoxicants lead to further Delusion" you said. Again you are generalizing, and I have had direct experience that is a logical counter-example to your claim. Not only did I have an experience which led to a temporary decrease in delusion, but this same experience caused me to realize the degree of delusion usually filling my mind when I was not on any drug. That is an important step in the process of decreasing delusion. Also, I would like to mention that meditation can cause delusion too. I know when I started meditating I would come away with delusional ideas. I still do, but less. Also you said "If they where a source of true happiness you would be without problems now." I have been following the Buddhist path, and I am not without problems now. So should I avoid meditating? No. Because it helps. That's the claim I am making about drugs. They can help. Another claim I have made is that no drug should be taken too many times, for various reasons. Please do not judge my words without reading them carefully.

    I hope I have made myself clear. I do approve of abstaining from drugs entirely even though they can be helpful. I just would like to share my observation of how helpful they can be.
  • FoibleFullFoibleFull Canada Veteran
    edited October 2010
    Tosh wrote: »
    I think I've made a start to realising what Emptiness is.

    I've had trouble with understanding this Emptiness business, but this evening I think I may have started to realise what it actually is.

    Here's some background first. I have a 14 year old daughter, with all the suffering that entails! But, for a few weeks now, when we interact together, I have been trying to imagine that she's my Mother from a previous life; and it's really been working and our relationship has greatly improved.

    It makes me speak to her on a more human-to-human level, rather than from an authoritarian position of father to daughter.

    I initially thought that this was because it deflates my ego when I speak to her; but a thought occurred to me that it could also be because when I imagine her to be my mother from a previous life, I am forgetting all about our previous history of stroppiness, bad behaviour, and cheekiness; i.e. I'm not labelling her in a negative way.

    So, is this a start to the realisation of 'Emptiness'?

    To NOT answer your question, I think we need to stop trying to measure our progress, especially using our mind to get us there when it is our thoughts that are a big part of the barrier to enlightenment. Relax and enjoy the journey.
Sign In or Register to comment.