Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

Rebirth of the Afghan Buddha

edited July 2011 in Buddhism Today
"When the Taliban controlled Afghanistan a decade ago, they were fanatical about eliminating everything they considered un-Islamic.

Their biggest targets — literally and figuratively — were the two monumental Buddha statues carved out of the sandstone cliffs in central Afghanistan. One stood nearly 180 feet tall and the other about 120 feet high, and together they had watched over the dusty Bamiyan Valley since the sixth century, several centuries before Islam reached the region.

Despite international opposition, the Taliban destroyed the statues with massive explosions in 2001. At the time they were blown up, the statues were the largest Buddha carvings in the world, and it seemed they were gone for good.

But today, teams from the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, along with the International Council on Monuments and Sites, are engaged in the painstaking process of putting the broken Buddhas back together."

Read the rest of the article here.

Personally, it would be great if the statues are restored - but the money could be spent more wisely. Such as caring for the country's poor and homeless. In the article, it says that many homeless people have taken shelter in the caves where the statues once stood. It seems that Buddha can always be a refuge - even if you blow him up!

Comments

  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    Thats thought provoking. Thanks for providing the description and the link.
  • edited July 2011
    Perhaps they can use this project as a way of employing the poor and homeless. This would provide them with a source of income, and would make their housing prospects a bit brighter.

    I suppose that if this is done properly, it could be a benefit for those who are desperately in need.
  • While I agree in principle, the fact is, this is a UNESCO World Heritage Site. If it is not restored now, it will deteriorate to such an extent that it may never be able to be restored. There will always be poor people, and we can always use any money we spend for anything else to help the poor. Sometimes we have to take the middle way...
  • GuiGui Veteran
    attachment to rocks. better to feed the poor and pray for those who blow up rocks out of fear.
  • vinlynvinlyn Colorado...for now Veteran
    attachment to rocks. better to feed the poor and pray for those who blow up rocks out of fear.
    The trouble with that is that you can say that about the vast majority of things man does. And the poor still won't learn to take care of themselves.

    Just the other day I was reading about established villages in -- well, I forgot whether it was Sudan or Somalia -- where there isn't a single toilet...so please contribute, blah, blah, blah. And I suddenly stopped to think -- what is wrong with this picture? It's 2011, and after all these centuries these people haven't cared enough to put even one toilet in their villages?????

    And why exactly do you think the Taliban is afraid of Buddhism -- a religion that in their country essentially no longer exists, and is in sharp decline in India, Singapore, and Japan? More like the dominance of Islam in their culture has been victorious.

  • edited July 2011
    @vinlyn


    :eek:
  • GuiGui Veteran
    Vinlyn, I did assume the Taliban blew up the rocks out of fear. It seemed logical to me that fear of ideas not Islamic would incite the destruction. I remember now that Islam prohibits images of God. How this relates to images of a buddha is not understood by me. There seems to be great irony in that act which I can't quite put my finger on. And I just don't really know why it was done. But I truly don't understand your remarks regarding compassion for those less fortunate than ourselves. I mean, it's ok to give nothing or everything or something. But to not give because someone should themselves have done something different is a mistake.


  • vinlynvinlyn Colorado...for now Veteran
    Vinlyn, I did assume the Taliban blew up the rocks out of fear. It seemed logical to me that fear of ideas not Islamic would incite the destruction. I remember now that Islam prohibits images of God. How this relates to images of a buddha is not understood by me. There seems to be great irony in that act which I can't quite put my finger on. And I just don't really know why it was done. But I truly don't understand your remarks regarding compassion for those less fortunate than ourselves. I mean, it's ok to give nothing or everything or something. But to not give because someone should themselves have done something different is a mistake.


    Stop putting words in my mouth.

    Nowhere did I say people shouldn't give to charities around the world. I regularly give to a medical mission in Guatemala (Partner For Surgery), for example. Have donated decent sums of money to orphanages in Thailand. I also sometimes contribute to feeding the poor in this country and recently contributed a significant amount of money to a mission in Kenya and another contribution to Save The Children Foundation. But I don't do those things INSTEAD of contributing to historical and national park-type efforts. I do those things IN ADDITION to.

    What I am questioning is this: I'm 61 years old now. For 55 years I've watched public service announcements on television that center around the theme of "save Africa". Africa is the continent which is probably richest in natural resources and has the oldest cultures. I'd like to know when the Africans are going to get their act together.
  • GuiGui Veteran
    Interesting how this forum can at times be a mirror. I was looking at me and thought I saw you!
    with apology to you, Vinlyn.
  • vinlynvinlyn Colorado...for now Veteran
    No apology needed. Forums and other "online environments" really don't lend themselves to full discussions. We write in shorthand and the whole story is rarely told until we need to clarify.
  • edited July 2011
    @vinlyn " When will Africa get its act together" isn't relevant to this thread. But start a thread on that topic under gen'l banter, and some of us will take you on! (I'm already rolling up my sleeves! ;) )
  • I watched a documentary on the Bamiyan Buddhas not too long ago. As another poster pointed out people lived in the caves around the statues. According to the documentary I watched those people were forcibly removed from those caves (their homes) and relocated far away from the village. Now they're pretty much in the middle of nowhere and far worse off than they were before. That strikes me as seriously wrong and a smack in the face of everything Buddhism is about. Buddhism teaches impermanence.The Bamiyan Buddhas are gone, that's it. Impermanent like everything else. Let the goddamn things remain a pile of rubble and give those people their lives back.
  • I watched a documentary on the Bamiyan Buddhas not too long ago. As another poster pointed out people lived in the caves around the statues. According to the documentary I watched those people were forcibly removed from those caves (their homes) and relocated far away from the village. Now they're pretty much in the middle of nowhere and far worse off than they were before. That strikes me as seriously wrong and a smack in the face of everything Buddhism is about. Buddhism teaches impermanence.The Bamiyan Buddhas are gone, that's it. Impermanent like everything else. Let the goddamn things remain a pile of rubble and give those people their lives back.
    +1

Sign In or Register to comment.