Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

Not To Associate With The Unwise Is Most Blissful.

HanzzeHanzze Veteran
edited October 2011 in Buddhism Basics
On the path its very important to have admiral friends to gain process, but even in daily live its good to chose his friends and companion wisely.

From the book: Mangala Sutta Uannana Ven. K. Gunaratana Thera


Not To Associate With The Unwise Is Most Blissful.

Fools or ignorant people not only injure themselves, but also those around them. If we associate with them, we are apt to follow their ways and so harm ourselves mentally as well as bodily, because all troubles or fear arise from ignorance or foolishness. Even if we do not practise their methods, the more fact of associating with them will harm our reputation; in the same way that a banana leaf is contaminated if it is used to wrap up a piece of rotten fish or meat. The leaf is dirty and smelly even after the fish or rotten meat is thrown away.

Here is a story to illustrate this:
Once, when the Bodhisat was born as a man called Akitti Pandita, the King of Devas promised to grant him any boon he asked. Akitti Pandita begged that he might never meet, see or talk with fools. The King of Devas was surprised and asked him the reason for this strange request. Replying, he explained that fools or the unwise ones i.e. people who do not understand discipline, always lead their friends to bad ways and teach them to do wrong, because they do not know the right way them selves. If discipline or good ways are spoken in their presence, they become angry, for they cannot understand, they lose their temper and quarrels arise. If discipline or good ways are spoken in their presence, they become angry, for they do not understand them. Therefore he prayed that he might never speak, meet or come in contact with fools.


There is a very good essay about good friends, teacher and "The Power of Judgment"

http://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/thanissaro/power_of_judgment.html

Thought very worthy for a discussion *smile*

Comments

  • On the path its very important to have admiral friends to gain process
    Sorry, but I don't know any admirals. The only friends I have in the navy are a Lieutenant Commander and a Captain.
  • "admirable" thanks! and sorry for my terrible english. *smile*
  • IronRabbitIronRabbit Veteran
    edited October 2011
    Hanzze - adjudging those on this forum who judge you as fools lacks compassion. As an observer of your rhetoric - and knowing this forum - your inability to communicate in anything other than admonition will surely gain your disassociation with this forum. It is only a matter of time. Are you capable of communicating in any other way than parroting sutra or anecdote? Do you wish to communicate or simply enjoy dwelling in the egoic conviction that all others are deluded except you. Your style of communication will not remain long in this forum - that is my prediction. All you need do is drop the superiority complex and share your own thoughts with the rest of us delusional humans on the path.
    I am betting you can't - won't do that. So, before the axe falls - I am wishing you a fond adieu.
  • Dear Iron Rabbit,

    Was there anything about the forum in the OP or did you take some attachments from another place?

    But back to the topic, you are right people judging others on there faults are mostly not good teacher.

    *smile*
  • let me quote something from the text, to get the topic rolling ontopic *smile*

    The first truth is that you can't really trust yourself to see through your delusion on your own.When you're deluded, you don't know you're deluded. You need some trustworthy outside help to point it out to you. This is why, when the Buddha advised the Kalamas to know for themselves, one of the things he told them to know for themselves was how wise people would judge their behavior. When he advised his son, Rahula, to examine his own actions as he would his face in a mirror, he said that if Rahula saw that his actions had caused any harm, he should talk it over with a knowledgeable friend on the path. That way he could learn how to be open with others — and himself — about his mistakes, and at the same time tap into the knowledge that his friend had gained. He wouldn't have to keep reinventing the dharma wheel on his own.

    So if you really want to become skillful in your thoughts, words, and deeds, you need a trustworthy friend or teacher to point out your blind spots. And because those spots are blindest around your unskillful habits, the primary duty of a trustworthy friend is to point out your faults — for only when you see your faults can you correct them; only when you correct them are you benefiting from your friend's compassion in pointing them out.
  • @Hanzze

    Seemingly you consider all of us "unwise" compared to you. Now wouldn't it just be blissful then to take your most learned self to another forum so that you can share your vast wealth of (other people's) knowledge with them? Somebody who truly appreciates what it is you are offering, since ostensibly we unwise folks don't?

    Just a suggestion, since clearly you feel we are inferior.

  • Maybe im just reading this differently from you guys, but when I read it I didn't feel like he was acting superior or anything, i thought i he was just sharing his opinions- anyway im not sure if I agree personally with the idea of not associating with the 'unwise'. Through association with people who are unwise, there is a possibility that we can be corrupted, certainly. But it works both ways, and someone who is going along the 'right' path could help those who are unwise get onto the same path. Also, if someone is being 'corrupted' by the unwise, I dont believe its the fault of the unwise but of the person themselves, who allowed themselves to be taken down the wrong path. Just my personal opinion =P
  • possibilitiespossibilities PNW, WA State Veteran
    @Hanzze

    "If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?"

  • edited October 2011
    Well, it's always good to get an outside perspective to help nudge us in the right direction. People need the support. One time Ananda approached Buddha as said, "This is half of the holy life, lord: admirable friendship, admirable companionship, admirable camaraderie."

    Buddha replied, "Don't say that, Ananda. Don't say that. Admirable friendship, admirable companionship, admirable camaraderie is actually the whole of the holy life. When a monk has admirable people as friends, companions, and comrades, he can be expected to develop and pursue the noble eightfold path."

    Don't think of this as an excuse to dump old friendships in place of "more spiritual" ones. Old friends can prove fertile ground for establishing an "admirable friendship", even if they have no interest in Buddhism at all.

    image

    :buck:
  • though i see where you and the buddha are getting at with this.
    and i see the merit and value in such teaching.

    i'm not sure it always applies. when we are well versed in the dharma and even our practice, it is paramount that we actively engage with the world. this is coming from a mahayana point of view.

    the friends that i have that are not so wise teach me lessons that i cannot ever learn from others.
    they teach me patience and more importantly they teach the willingness to open the heart towards them.
    sure they are flawed and are ignorant, but we all are. they are a part of us.

    what use is freedom for myself if i cannot help others? if i cannot be sad or happy with them? if i cannot fall and cry in misery with them?

    suffering is okay. i don't mind it. to be awakened from suffering and non suffering. this gives me the strength to help everyone.

    such is bliss.

    i do see your point though.
  • Maybe im just reading this differently from you guys, but when I read it I didn't feel like he was acting superior or anything, i thought i he was just sharing his opinions- anyway im not sure if I agree personally with the idea of not associating with the 'unwise'. Through association with people who are unwise, there is a possibility that we can be corrupted, certainly. But it works both ways, and someone who is going along the 'right' path could help those who are unwise get onto the same path. Also, if someone is being 'corrupted' by the unwise, I dont believe its the fault of the unwise but of the person themselves, who allowed themselves to be taken down the wrong path. Just my personal opinion =P
    @YoungBuddhist Perhaps you have not been privy to the multitude of threads that Hanzze has been posting to. Have a look through, and you will see why there are some of us taking exception to his constant quotations of other people's work, and superior attitude. He's not so much contributing as trying to be right above all else.
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    I think we'll call a halt to this before it gets any further.
This discussion has been closed.