Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

How to Deal with the Flames

MegMeg
edited February 2011 in Buddhism Basics
I live in "The South" (USA), and attend a small, fundamentalist Christian school. My classroom consists of students (many who are close minded, this-is-what-I-grew-up-with-so-it-must-be right attitudes) that have hardcore-conservative views on Christianity. My question, how can I avoid the tongue lashings and "you're going to burn in hell" speeches for the rest of my senior year?
Thanks,
Meg :)
«1

Comments

  • Who let the cat out of the bag? Do they know your Buddhist, or do they do that to anyone who isn't signed up with their team, even those who are on no team (atheist/agnostic)? How do your teachers feel about it; are they more mellow and respectful of diversity? Might you be able to find an ally among your teachers?
  • Ask them whether they are more right than Muslims who *know* that theirs is the "one true faith" (same God, same Old Testament), and if so why. And why then are there more Muslims in the world than Christians? Ask them if it is more right to believe in the Christian God (and likely in their case, more of a cult of Jesus) than to believe in the basic goodness of humans and to work for a more peaceful and better world, regardless of one's faith?

    Of course, if you do any of those things with hard core right wing "Christians" you'll be in a no-win argument, so it's really not worth it. The best you can do is to point out that you respect their religious beliefs with great humility, and ask that they respect yours with equal humility. It was their individual choice to be (or remain) "Christians", just as it's your choice to embrace Buddhism (or Islam, or Ba'hai, or Hinduism, or shamanism, or whatever).

    As for the "you're going to burn in hell" thing, tell them that in order to burn there, one would first have to believe that there is such a place and thus be afraid of going there. If neither of those things is true, then it's not a worry. Also, tell them that people who live in glass houses....

    My best suggestion would be to move to a more enlightened place. Not easy to do, I know, but ultimately you'd probably be much happier.
  • But in order to move, Meg would have to convince her parents to move, leaving job/s, and maybe there are siblings as well. Unless there's a relative somewhere else who'd be willing to take her in. Anyway, it's just a few more months, and then she'll be done, and hopefully off to a secular college.
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    "I hope you feel happy and fulfilled with that conclusion. I don't agree with it, but it's your right to have it."

    And smile, and offer them a really nice sweet.
    if they take it, they can't really hate you that much, can they?
  • Compassionate Warrior:
    Nope, not a one of 'em. :P I doubt I will tell them, because just as Mountains stated, I'll be up for a no-win argument. I've watched these people bash other religions in the ground with chunks of metaphorical brimstone (lemme tell ya, NOT pretty ). Honestly, I don't think it would be worth my time to tell them, go thru with a cornered argument, let it interfere with my education, and ruin my future.

    Compassionate Warrior AND Mountains:
    Uprooting at this time is a no-go. :-/ For one: I'm expecting a baby sister in May (first sibling :D ), so there's really no money to spare. (also, parents don't actually support me in my "new religion"- not to say they discourage me either! :) ). And even though the students and teachers throw boo's and hiss' in my direction, I really like the curriculem. Even though it's fundamentalist-Christianity based, it implies good morals and challenges me. I doubt I'd get that in a public school.





  • awe, fruit.. Sorry, typo. I meant "curriculum". :)
  • For some details on what you may be facing check this book out: "The Mind of the Bible Believer" - Edmund D. Cohen.

    Good luck! :-/
  • Thanks Roger! :) You guys are really helping, Thanks!
  • I wish I had some advice on dealing with these folks, but for yourself it is a good opportunity to develop patience.
    Ask them whether they are more right than Muslims who *know* that theirs is the "one true faith" (same God, same Old Testament), and if so why. And why then are there more Muslims in the world than Christians?
    That isn't actually true. There are roughly 1.5 billion Muslims in the world while Christians number over 2 billion.
  • zenffzenff Veteran
    edited February 2011
    What could help maybe is to know that they (the fundamentalists) suffer from their closed-mindedness and feel some compassion for them.

    It’s a pretty horrible thing to really believe in hell. For instance when you really believe that someone you love (like your child) will be burning in flames for all eternity.
    Anyone who believes in hell is in some kind of hell already – the hell of fear.

    The best connection we can make with Christians is on the softer parts of their religion; love and compassion, forgiveness, turning the other cheek; the things we have in common.
    The fundamentalists are ignoring essential (the happy and friendly) pieces of their own religion.

    Another opening can be that fundamentalist “thinkers” are really arrogant. They seem to know it all. That too is basically not a very Christian attitude. Christian people could be expected to be more humble next to “God’s greatness”.
    Sometimes some inter-religious common ground can be found in this humble not-knowing.

    Anyways, good luck to you.; and keep in touch with kind people.
  • shanyinshanyin Novice Yogin Sault Ontario Veteran
    edited February 2011
    .
  • shanyinshanyin Novice Yogin Sault Ontario Veteran
    edited February 2011
    .
  • Tell them Jesus loves buddhists too.
  • seeker242seeker242 Zen Florida, USA Veteran
    edited February 2011
    You can avoid "you're going to burn in hell" speeches by viewing these people not as "close minded fundamental Christians" but simply as human beings trying to find happiness, just like you and sincerely wishing that they find it. You already wish that they can find happiness and already wish for them to not suffer, right? I think you do. :) With practicing and developing this "metta" or loving kindness, "you're going to burn in hell" speeches can be avoided, even if you are being bombarded with them on a daily basis.
  • Very interesting, seeker242. A good experiment for Meg: can she rise above or beyond the samsara.

    Stay in touch, Meg; let us know how you're doing. :)
  • question: what exactly is samsara? never heard that term before :/
  • question: what exactly is samsara? never heard that term before :/
    In a word, "suffering". More loosely, it refers to all the crazy stuff people do to each other for deluded reasons ("ignorance") that causes unnecessary pain. But it refers to all manner of suffering as well; illness, old age, death, etc.

  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    edited February 2011
    samsara means caught up in: gaining, pleasure, praise, and fame. And avoiding their opposite. And all the mental tricks we play (see compassionate warriors answer above).

    Nirvana is to accept the way things are (though not despair) and develope curiosity (new eyes) not assuming you know everything. Wide open.
  • ah.. I see.. :)
  • another aspect of samsara are the 6 paths of reoncarnation. I expect you've heard of those :D
  • vaguely.. like I said, I'm a bit new :)

    BTW, told my cousin yesterday that I converted.. He was cool with it, surprisingly :)
  • The six realms of reincarnation are ; Hell, hungry spirit,animal,human,asura,deva. Hell is temporary which is against christian belief, to go along with impermanence. And awesome about you cousin! :)
  • whoa, wait.. I thought Mountains said:


    As for the "you're going to burn in hell" thing, tell them that in order to burn there, one would first have to believe that there is such a place and thus be afraid of going there.
    so.. In Buddhism, is Hell, just a temporary "burn you according to your 'degree' of badness (pun intended ;) )" place? Does Satan control Hell, like in the Christian perspective?
  • Sorta like that, minus the Satan. It's not a real hell, but another plane of existence or lower form of existence (perhaps animal), and karma is the only master though it's a natural process and not "controlled".
  • Mara is the "Satan" of Buddhism sorta. he "feeds" on the desire of this world. if I remember correctly
  • CloudCloud Veteran
    edited February 2011
    Mara is delusion/ignorance, so you could say that's the master of all suffering in the mind, and so all existence. Doesn't have to be a real being... suffering is mind-made. :)
  • zenffzenff Veteran
    edited February 2011
    There’s a new option for you.
    When Christians tell you that you will end op in Christian hell, you can tell them that – on the contrary – they are going to end up in Buddhist hell.
    Isn’t religion a beautiful thing?
    :rolleyes:
  • CloudCloud Veteran
    edited February 2011
    lol
    also a funny thing, a Buddhist can go to "heaven" in this very life, without having to die to find out :D
  • hahaha :)
  • I find in buddhism its extremly hard to go to heaven or hell hahahah a human life is actually sort of rare they say
  • Yes, human life is rare, but the payoff is that it's the perfect plane of existence from which to end the cycle of suffering, to awaken.
  • Another way to look at samsara is 'spinning' through the cycle of birth, life, suffering and death.

    I had an interesting discussion with a person who sees the different realms as part of the human existence - more as a state of mind than actually being reborn as an animal or such.

    http://www.drgabormate.com/ghosts.php
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    edited February 2011
    your 'person' is not the only one. The realms of existence are seen by many to be allegorical, and it's easy to see why.

    I think if we're honest, we've all visited them at some time or another, during any ordinary day.
    I know I probably stop off at more than one....

    I'm in agreement.
    This is why in Buddhism, the state of your Mind at the moment you cease living this life, is so important as a stepping stone into the next existence.
    If you buy that kind of thing, that is. :)
  • Meg, I don't live in the South but have still encountered this sort of attitude. A boy on the schoolbus harassed one of my children for not being Christian and once tried to trip her as she was going down the aisle. I contacted the school about it and to my relief, it was dealt with appropriately.

    I am not saying that you have to do the same. In our case, it was the fact that it got physical and some of the things the boy said crossed a certain line for me. Also my child (in 2nd grade at the time) was starting to dread going to school. Anyway, but if anyone acts out in a physical way, or if the things said start to depress you or interfere with your schoolwork, you may want to consider talking to a trusted teacher or counselor.

    But I also encourage my kids to work these things out by themselves if they can do so safely.

    This may not be the case, but sometimes fundamentalist Christians are just trying to help, like someone telling you not to smoke so you don't get lung cancer. In that case it may help to realize they mean well.

    OTOH students your age often do not mean well! I have noticed a lot of teens at our local schools run in packs, dressing the same way, liking the same music, etc... There's a lot of pressure for everyone to conform and anyone who doesn't can seem like a threat. They are insecure and you could try being compassionate about that, though of course it's hard when they are working out their issues on you.

    I hope some of this helps and wish you the best.
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    edited February 2011
    Hell represents agression and anger. heaven represents pride. Human represents attachment. Hungry ghost represents craving. Animal represents Ignorance. Titan represents Jealousy.

    Nirvana is liberation of the heart. From these realms.

    The difference between heaven and nirvana. In heaven you love the people who make you feel good. In nirvana you will let yourself feel bad (not doormat I mean worry sadness) in order to love people.
  • edited February 2011
    Thanks Roger! :) You guys are really helping, Thanks!
    We're glad to help. :thumbsup: There are a bunch of books on these things; below are my favorites I read a few years ago. AFAIK, These are almost "the classics." ;) Hey! They might even be interesting to you just for your own edification; human beings ARE fascinating! IOW, read them not only for the "Dealing with Flames" issue. Good luck again!!! :)

    "The God Virus: How religion infects our lives and culture" by Darrel W. Ray
    "God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything" by Christopher Hitchens
    "The God Delusion" by Richard Dawkins



  • one down, fifteen to go :P
    Today the other senior (yeah, there's just two.. :wow: )at my school noticed me reading a book on Buddhism, preceded to ask me about it and if I was a Buddhist.
    I explained about the eightfold path, noble truths and life of Siddhartha. Of course, she quickly tried to pull my soul off this path. :rolleyes: We discussed how we felt about our religions, and agreed to be respectful to one another. :) Maybe it won't be so bad after all.. or at least, with the actual "Christ-like" Christians..
  • Good for you, Meg! There's hope for humanity, yet (at least in your school). Congrats on a job well done. :clap:
  • :clap:
  • Maybe it won't be so bad after all.. or at least, with the actual "Christ-like" Christians..
    The thing that drives me most insane is when Christians attack you for not believing in their peace loving leader XD
  • “I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ.” -Mahatma Gandhi :-/
  • sadly true... :(
  • BarraBarra soto zennie wandering in a cloud in beautiful, bucolic Victoria BC, on the wacky left coast of Canada Veteran
    Gandhi's quote has some merit, but I don't think that a Buddhist would say that. I think that a Buddhist would try to show compassion for all people that cross their path.
    I suggest that you do not speak this quote to the Christians around you. They will take offense.
    I come from a fundamental Christian family (Calvinists) and my oldest sister, referring to our niece, said "Oh, I hear that Marie is a Buddhist!" (spitting out the last word). I said "Yes, she is." But I totally wimped out about saying that I am as well. My approach growing up in that family was just not to bring up topics that I thought would be upsetting or controversial for them, since they would feel honor bound to argue with me and to try to save my soul. I would just step aside.
  • CloudCloud Veteran
    edited February 2011
    @Meg, Love the quote, but I agree with Barra that Christians would be offended by that. Not only that, but it only applies to the speech and actions of some Christians. There are those who try and emulate Jesus and live in peace and harmony, exercising compassion for all others. (The same could be said for Buddhists!)
  • It's more important to become a buddha, than a buddhist. I think it's fine to keep quiet about your spiritual practice and beliefs.
  • who ever said I said that to anyone? It was something Gandhi said, it was relevant, so I thought I'd mention it. I never said I was going to go up to a Christian and say that to them. :confused:
  • I actually think the Christianity's hell is meant allegorical as well. It's just the interpretation of the teaching, what's perceived literally by most of the followers.
    Don't worry, Meg. To follow and understand Buddhism does not mean, that you have to claim to be a Buddhist. It's very irrelevant and can even become a nuisance on the path.
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    I like another of his quotations:
    Journalist/Interviewer: "Mr Gandhi, what do you think of Western civilisation?"
    Gandhi: "I think it would be a very good idea."
  • Then again I think his methods worked with the British for a reason. The nazis would have happily mown down millions of Gandhi's followers without so much as blinking.
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    The British did the same. Check your history.
    Haven't you heard of the Amritsar Massacre?

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jallianwala_Bagh_massacre
Sign In or Register to comment.