
Plogging journal: so the street right in front of my house is cleaner than ever and today, while cleaning my own garden, I decided to plant some remaining aloe vera that have been removed from the main aloe vera plants. The aloe vera developed many "children" around the main plant. I removed many of them and managed to make this.
Courtesy of Lisa that took the picture from the balcony.
Kotishka
Thinking that the path towards suffering's cessation is only a transition from the material to the spiritual, misses the point that this path's destination is really about a transcending of all attachments, not just the ones we might consider to be unrefined.
The sides of this path are littered with the remains of teachers who somehow forgot that this fundamental truth still applied to them.
As long as a seeking, by either a teacher or a student, remains attachment bound, it will contribute to suffering's creation.
When that seeking allows some transcendence of what we cling to, reject or ignore, it illuminates the way toward suffering's cessation.
The quicker we can act as if we are not separate beings that can be divided off into self & other, teachers & students, enlightened and unenlightened, the quicker that our mental equivocations stop obscuring the path towards suffering's cessation that's just the next step to take...even when its often 3 steps forward, two back.
how
Here too! But only before the elections.
Kotishka
OP, I've heard recently a teaching on two freedoms and how they are not the freedom offered by Dharma. There is freedom from and freedom to. Freedom from x, y, z. In a way a lot of what we do is try to attain freedom from oppression, from our traumas, from even suffering. Or freedom to x, y, z. Freedom to live a good life. Freedom to do whatever we want to. Dharma offers a freedom that isn't from or to.
This teaching that was impressed upon me really shocked me because pretty much everything I do is well for those two modes of freedom. And even my dharma practice is about getting freedom from suffering and freedom to live a fuller life. But freedom in the dharma is something else entirely.
And thus I am presented with two things. My spiritual materialism and something so radical that my conventional mind cannot make sense of it.
taiyaki
It's true that there are many kinds of freedom. Freedom to. Freedom from. Etc. But much of that is theoretical and linguistic and not necessarily an objective reality. For one, we have start with our metaphysical assumptions about agency. Do we have free will? Is the world causally deterministic? Etc. For true freedom to exist, there must be an agency free to choose. And I think it's difficult to pinpoint such an agency. We are conditioned by a myriad of factors. Biological. Psychological. Cultural. Etc. Often, when we think we are free to make a choice, the decision has been conditioned by a host of factors, and we fill in the reasoning afterwards, as if it was a free choice.
And then for the types of freedom, we are also constrained and conditioned for both good and bad reasons. One can be constrained by morality and social conventions that have been learned to be generous, for example. We are free to be generous, but acts of generosity often have conditions behind them, meaning that are not entirely free. Or we can be free from things like hunger, but that freedom will depend upon whether or not we have access to food, and various internal and external conditions can effect that freedom. We may eat because we are hungry, biological factors triggering the decision. Or we may abstain because of social factors making us feel self-conscious about our appearance. And while we fee that we have made the choice to eat or not eat, it's very difficult to say if we were indeed free to make them.
Besides these philosophical debates, we do tend to want more freedom and dislike being told we are not able to do something we desire, or suffer something we do not wish to suffer. This is the heart of the the first noble truth and the teachings on not-self. The Buddha notes that we cannot say, 'Let my form be thus, let my form be not thus. Let my feeling be thus, let my feeling be not thus. Let my perception be thus, let my perception be not thus. Let my determination be thus, let my determination be not thus. Let my consciousness be thus, let my consciousness be not thus' (SN 22.59), so what type of freedom do we actually have? Perhaps the path helps to decondition us and allows us more freedom. Or perhaps we become free from the idea of freedom and see causality for what it is, and use it to help condition ourselves to the freedom of nonattachment.
I'm not sure which is closer to the truth, but I do think that we often believe we have more freedom than we actually do. The mention of capitalism is one area where we are told we have freedom, freedom to work where we want and buy what we want because the markets are 'free.' As David Harvey notes in Limits to Capital, workers are, in principle, "free to sell their labour under whatever conditions of contract (for whatever length of working day) they please" (30), which highlights the equality, freedom, and individuality characterizing exchange relations, recalling both Aristotle's argument that "exchange cannot take place without equality" and Marx's argument that "the circulation of commodities requires the exchange of equivalents" (19). However, workers must also compete against one another in the labour market, where capitalists who are forced to internalize the profit-seeking motive due to the coercive laws of competition purchase workers' labour time with the sole purpose being the accumulation of profit (accumulation for accumulation's sake), and who more often than not dictate the duration and conditions of labour workers must accept or else risk privation while seeking something better, putting workers at a disadvantage on an individual level and severely conditioning and restricting their choices.
And an argument can be made that the logic of the economic system itself, which is effectively omnipresent, compels both the capitalist and the worker to do what they do. Even if there is a choice being made to do x or not to do x, that choice is not one free from causes or conditions and both internal and external pressures and we're often unaware of all of them. And I think that to try and uncover objective freedom in this or any other aspect of our lives is like the search for the heartwood of a banana tree. You peel back layer after layer only to discover that it's ultimately "empty, void, without substance" (SN 22.95). We feel like we have freedom, and we feel that we make rational choices. And conventionally, it makes sense to talk in this way about being free to do this or that, or of being free from this or that. But like the self, I think that freedom is a useful fiction.
Jason
Don't try to be successful. Anyone can be successful.
Be a person of value. Being valuable, takes effort.
Albert Einstein.
federica