Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

Are we empty shells?

betaboybetaboy Veteran
edited July 2011 in Buddhism Basics
Are we?

Take away the things we've accumulated, the ideas and knowledge we've acquired, the habits we've formed ... and what are we? We are empty when all this is taken away. So is emptiness our true nature, then? If so, where to go from here?

BB

Comments

  • taiyakitaiyaki Veteran
    it's pretty obvious. you get on with it. live life. express yourself.
    help others. do what excites you the most in every moment.
    you know that everything is going to be okay.

    form is emptiness and emptiness is form. they are both the same.
    enjoy life.
  • Right view teaches us that the only way out of emptiness is to not create karma and detachment from cravings, only then shall we really know.

    The answer to our questions can be experienced in this lifetime if one remains true and dedicated in practice.
  • taiyakitaiyaki Veteran
    also i think it's important to note that emptiness isn't a philosophical assertion. it is something to be realized, along with our non dual awareness. though one can realize both at the same time and it does happen.

    also learning how to integrate and learning how suchness moves about in this world is a whole different matter. so while it is interesting to ponder what life is going to be life after awakening, it truly is impossible to understand unless you yourself experience such realizations.

    but in essence you start operating from being which is a holistic approach to living life where your mind, body, emotions, and consciousness all operate as one collective unity. And most stream winners deal with their remaining karmic tendencies,so there is a gradual falling into their awakening/realizations.

    also as i mentioned above one may realize their non dual awareness, but not realize the emptiness of reality. one can also get caught in emptiness or even non dual awareness. but the learning keeps unfolding as we interact with others and the world. in some sense there is an authenticity and integrity with engaging with the world and it's inhabitants.

    contrary to what many people believe/assume there are a lot of awakened individuals in our society. most of them are just normal people like you and i. but lately more and more people are awakening, so it's fair to assume that there is something in the air Lol.
  • Are we?

    Take away the things we've accumulated, the ideas and knowledge we've acquired, the habits we've formed ... and what are we? We are empty when all this is taken away. So is emptiness our true nature, then? If so, where to go from here?

    BB
    You don't necessarily take away the ideas and knowledge we've acquired, and hopefully by following the Dharma we develop more skillful habits. We sort out the things we've accumulated and take the Dharmically skillful ones and leave the rest. Then we recognize (skillfully) that these things are empty of inherent existence but necessary to function in the world- and we function in the world more skillfully. If we take away the things you mention, it would be difficult to function in the world. The point is to function in the world skillfully, not to be "empty shells". We need a vehicle to function in the world skillfully.
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    Good answer. I would add that we are not bound by our knowledge. That is how it is empty. We can learn more and adapt.
  • We are not empty shells. Not only is there no us, there is also no empty shell.
    "you" are a temporary formation in the sea of life.
    You are not living life. Life is living itself, and you are part of it.
    Even then, you are not going with the flow. You are part of the flow.
    Practice choiceless awareness as your true nature, and see how things continue as they always have without "you" doing anything.
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    Making choices is appearance-emptiness
  • genkakugenkaku Northampton, Mass. U.S.A. Veteran
    I guess it is good to consider from time to time, who would I be without my car and job and relationships and beliefs and shoelaces and toothbrush?

    If you come up with "empty," that still suggests there is something to be filled.

    But if things are "empty," how could that possibly be so?

    Intellectually and emotionally, all this can create a deliciously confounding philosophy or belief system or something similar. Better, I think, is to foster a determined meditation practice and find out what is actually what.
  • Bodha8Bodha8 Veteran
    Asking questions, just for the sake of asking questions, is emptiness.

    Namaste
  • seeker242seeker242 Zen Florida, USA Veteran
    If so, where to go from here?
    To the meditation cushion. :)

  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    If we are empty space there is no attaining. So we can go wherever we wish.
  • God... you guys are so depressing. I follow another religion very similar to Buddhism called Sant Mat but we believe in God. And we all have a soul. We meditate on God and our soul using the natural organic energies of our bodies to find out what we are and we are filled with bliss. We have visions of beauty and our selves are healed. We live in a state of joy everyday.

    You are not nothing! You are everything!

    According to our religion Buddha did not attain full enlightenment. Full enlightenment in our religion is union with God in pure Love and Light like we're supposed to. Like we all want to. Not this emptiness I'm nothing crap. Jeez...

    What comes easier to you? Do you want EMPTINESS or do you want Love and Light and Beauty? Go with your instinct now... Of course you want Love and Light and Beauty. It's programmed in! Duh. And it's waiting for all of us.









  • @milkmoth

    you mistook Buddhism with Nihilism.
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    With no attaining there is no reason for fear.
  • @milkmoth- you should do your homework on Buddhism before you go on and on like that. And don't ask me "What do you mean?"- don't expect me to do your research for you. The topic is "The extreme of nihilism (in Buddhism)". I suggest Google.

  • mugzymugzy Veteran
    edited July 2011
    @milkmoth I think the concept of emptiness in Buddhism is one that is often misunderstood.

    There is a book available online by Lama Zopa Rinpoche on this topic. You can read it here - How Things Exist: Teachings on Emptiness. Here's an excerpt from chapter 2:

    The nature of our mind is clear light; it is empty of existing from its own side. The mind is a phenomenon that the self possesses. It is non-substantial, colorless, shapeless and clear in nature; it has the ability to perceive objects; and it is not an object of the five senses. That is one way to define the mind. In dependence upon this base, a phenomenon that has such characteristics, we have labeled, or merely imputed, “mind.” Therefore, there’s no mind existing from its own side; there’s no real mind from its own side. Mind is nothing other than that which we have merely imputed by our mind in dependence upon that base, that particular phenomenon. Therefore there’s no such thing as a real mind from its own side. The mind is empty of existing from its own side. That is one definition of the clear light nature of the mind, which refers to its ultimate nature.

    This ultimate nature of the mind, this clear light nature, is not oneness with the obscurations, the disturbing thoughts. Because of that, in dependence upon causes and conditions, obscurations can be eliminated.
  • edited July 2011
    @mugzy- I'm not sure Lama Zopa explains that as well as I'd like. Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche does a good job of it in his first books, "The Joy of Living: Unlocking the Secret and Science of Happiness" or "Joyful Wisdom", but I haven't found any articles by him online.

    http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_ss_c_1_23?url=search-alias=stripbooks&field-keywords=yongey+mingyur+rinpoche&sprefix=yongey+mingyur+rinpoche

    In any case, I think it stands as a valid corollary to the "God within", in both brilliance and permanence.
  • taiyakitaiyaki Veteran
    there is a difference between the lack of something verses nothing.

    silence is non dual. emptiness is non dual.

    emptiness is a fullness and a fullness is an emptiness. form is emptiness and emptiness is form.

    blah blah blah blah blah
  • Ok @milkmoth, sorry to dissapoint you but this is a Buddhist forum, even I who have a very diverse belief system on spirituality respect that and am not attacking my fellow members by saying 'oh guys you're so depressing'. If you feel that, then you haven't got what Buddhism is really about....
  • santhisouksanthisouk Veteran
    edited July 2011
    Short explanation on emptiness: Don't cling to emptiness. Don't attach to emptiness.
  • there is a difference between the lack of something verses nothing.

    silence is non dual. emptiness is non dual.

    emptiness is a fullness and a fullness is an emptiness. form is emptiness and emptiness is form.

    blah blah blah blah blah
    :p

  • taiyakitaiyaki Veteran
    lol cling all you want. if you can hahahhahahaha.
  • mugzymugzy Veteran
    I'm not sure Lama Zopa explains that as well as I'd like.
    @SherabDorje Yes thank you for pointing this out. The book by Lama Zopa is okay, but I agree that there are more eloquent writings on the subject. I wanted to share it because it's free and was the first thing that came to mind when I read @milkmoth's comment.
    Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche does a good job of it in his first books, "The Joy of Living: Unlocking the Secret and Science of Happiness" or "Joyful Wisdom", but I haven't found any articles by him online.
    These are excellent recommendations! I had the great pleasure of receiving teachings and empowerment from Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche. He is a wonderful teacher. I updated the links for the books you provided in the quote :)
  • edited July 2011
    I had the great pleasure of receiving teachings and empowerment from Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche. He is a wonderful teacher. I updated the links for the books you provided in the quote :)
    You're a very lucky man. If I wasn't Buddhist I'd be almost envious. :D

    Thanks for doing that with the links. I have no idea how to do it. And at my advanced age I don't know if I could learn how or not.

    It must have been great fun with YM Rinpoche. If anyone shows a good example of happiness in Buddhism and the lack of "ultimate emptiness" it is he. HHDL, of course, refers to himself as a "professional laugher".

    Somebody posted something about the Web of Indra last week and the TB description of the luminosity of the very subtle consciousness reminds me very much of that. I mean, they don't call it the "Diamond Vehicle" for nothing, right?

    And again, I think this stands as a very valid corollary to what other belief systems call the God Within. "Tomato, tomahto, potato, potahtoe."

  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    edited July 2011
    God... you guys are so depressing.
    We are not depressing. if you find something depressing, it's you who are depressed. we're absolutely fine with what we have, thanks. you're the one objecting.
    I follow another religion very similar to Buddhism called Sant Mat
    How very nice for you.
    We - don't.
    but we believe in God. And we all have a soul.
    That's your opinion. We'll have to agree to differ on that one....
    We meditate on God and our soul using the natural organic energies of our bodies to find out what we are and we are filled with bliss.
    "organic energies"? I'm sorry, breaking wind springs to mind....
    We have visions of beauty and our selves are healed. We live in a state of joy everyday.
    Join the club!
    You are not nothing! You are everything!
    We are nothing and we are everything, and we are not-nothing and we are not-everything.
    Just to be more salient.
    According to our religion Buddha did not attain full enlightenment.
    Again, that's just your opinion, and again, we'll have to agree to differ.
    Full enlightenment in our religion is union with God in pure Love and Light like we're supposed to. Like we all want to. Not this emptiness I'm nothing crap. Jeez...
    The fact you think it's crap, shows just how little you know. Try doing some research before being so ignorantly disparaging.

    ok?
    What comes easier to you? Do you want EMPTINESS or do you want Love and Light and Beauty? Go with your instinct now... Of course you want Love and Light and Beauty. It's programmed in! Duh. And it's waiting for all of us.
    Why wait? we have it now, thanks....

    And we also have BOTH 'Emptiness' (in the accurate sense of the word) AND "Love, light and beauty".
    So I guess you need to go back to the drawing board and do a little more reading up on it.
  • DaltheJigsawDaltheJigsaw Mountain View Veteran
    Sometimes.
  • Are we?

    Take away the things we've accumulated, the ideas and knowledge we've acquired, the habits we've formed ... and what are we? We are empty when all this is taken away. So is emptiness our true nature, then? If so, where to go from here?

    BB
    No, we are not empty shells. There is no shell.

    As for where to go.... you can either go that way, towards Sukha... or that way, towards Dukka. DP 282.
  • JasonJason God Emperor Arrakis Moderator
    Can't we all just get along? :p
  • DaozenDaozen Veteran
    ...
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    edited July 2011
    We are shells, but then we stuff them with bacon, cheese, love, courage, truth, harmony, and all of the distinct yet ungraspable buddha qualities.
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    Pardon me if I pass on the bacon..... ;)
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    its bacos I swear
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    ungraspable bacos
  • ZaylZayl Veteran
    I am just a human being. I can rest easy knowing that I have made an impact on everything I have interacted with. Whether it is people, or the planet itself. Long after I am gone those imprints will still be there, in one way or another.
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    Zayl, you have to ask yourself whether the impact you leave, puts a smile on people's faces, or a frown.
    The difference is monumental.
  • We are shells, but then we stuff them with bacon, cheese, love, courage, truth, harmony, and all of the distinct yet ungraspable buddha qualities.
    No, no, no... we put hamburger or chicken in the bottom part, and top that with lettuce, cheese, tomato, and chili- we can all be taco shells. And we won't be empty shells then.

  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    Sherab, If its available at a drive thru I'm in!
  • DaltheJigsawDaltheJigsaw Mountain View Veteran
    I am just a human being. I can rest easy knowing that I have made an impact on everything I have interacted with. Whether it is people, or the planet itself. Long after I am gone those imprints will still be there, in one way or another.
    Beautifully said!

  • It's empty in a sense that it exist, but not TRULLY exist. Meaning we're just composite of many parts like limbs, head... compound togather and not exist independantly....
    things come together due to cause, condition, and effect, and the effect is our body's existance....

    Well, u can see tbe body as ever changing flux of energy and matter.... moleculs come in and out of body... we take in water and food and release CO2..... a big cluster of vibrating atoms, constantly changing.

    It's there, yet it's changing so much that it's not "solid" enough to be trully exist.... it will fade away within a century..... (impermenance, emptiness)

    I think that's what the "emptiness" is about... rather than taking the term "emptiness" literally and view our selves as hollow shell....
    it's more like a flux of ever changing energy n matter that comes and goes due to cause, condition, and effect... and dependant arising.

  • God... you guys are so depressing. I follow another religion very similar to Buddhism called Sant Mat but we believe in God. And we all have a soul. We meditate on God and our soul using the natural organic energies of our bodies to find out what we are and we are filled with bliss. We have visions of beauty and our selves are healed. We live in a state of joy everyday.

    You are not nothing! You are everything!

    According to our religion Buddha did not attain full enlightenment. Full enlightenment in our religion is union with God in pure Love and Light like we're supposed to. Like we all want to. Not this emptiness I'm nothing crap. Jeez...

    What comes easier to you? Do you want EMPTINESS or do you want Love and Light and Beauty? Go with your instinct now... Of course you want Love and Light and Beauty. It's programmed in! Duh. And it's waiting for all of us.

    In buddhism emptiness is only the beginning

  • Lovely dooey sounds like candy illusion to me
    create a cult and put a lot of love n light and beauty, and a little smiley huggy and u can get a lot of followers who enjoy such illusion.
    this kind of thing fades with time.
Sign In or Register to comment.