Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

The economy. Will it ever be fixed?

edited November 2011 in Buddhism Today
I can't quite decide whether or not I think the economy will ever be fixed. I'm not a very bright person and I don't think I'm qualified to make any kind of decision. But this country has just reached 1,000,000 unemployed 16-24 year olds and with everything that's happening with the euro and wall street...

It's hard to decide whether or not I'll ever be able to get a job where I have any worker's rights or that isn't temporary.

Just makes me start looking at monasteries again.

Comments

  • The economy will only be fixed if there's the political will to fix it, and in the US, there isn't. Economies are so interconnected these days, that if the US keeps screwing up, it'll affect the rest of the world as well. But yes, the issues with the Euro are also a big factor affecting the global economy, too. Honestly, I don't know what "they" were thinking, creating one economic zone and including weak economies like Greece and Portugal. Not to mention Latvia and Lithuania, which crashed and burned years ago already. I don't know if they were part of the Euro zone, but they raked in a lot of cheap loans from the European union, which created a bubble that burst messily. Here in the US, it looks like a wholesale government take-over by corporate interests. Even more so than before. I think that's what all the Republican road-blocking of economic recovery policies is about.
  • JasonJason God Emperor Arrakis Moderator
    I can't quite decide whether or not I think the economy will ever be fixed. I'm not a very bright person and I don't think I'm qualified to make any kind of decision. But this country has just reached 1,000,000 unemployed 16-24 year olds and with everything that's happening with the euro and wall street...

    It's hard to decide whether or not I'll ever be able to get a job where I have any worker's rights or that isn't temporary.

    Just makes me start looking at monasteries again.
    Personally, I don't think it'll ever be 'fixed' since the way its currently structured is inherently unstable, not to mention antagonistic towards the working-class in general.
  • personperson Don't believe everything you think The liminal space Veteran
    It depends on how you define ever. Will it be fixed in a couple months or a couple years? That seems unlikely. Will it be fixed in 20-30 years? Quite possibly. Will it be fixed in 200-300 years? Almost certainly, in fact it will probably have been fixed and broken several times by then.

    The point is these things kind of go in cycles. Its not to say that people aren't responsible but when times are good we tend to get soft and forget the lessons of the difficult times. Our politics may be broken due to a lack of political will right now, but if things get bad enough people will be mad as hell and they won't take it anymore which should hopefully light a fire under the butts of the politicians.

    In Buddhism we try not to put too much of our hopes and happiness in external factors because of their inherent unreliability.
  • DakiniDakini Veteran
    edited November 2011
    Will it be fixed in 200-300 years? Almost certainly
    Good point, but Sagat can't wait 200 years, or even 20-30 years for a job.

    if things get bad enough people will be mad as hell and they won't take it anymore which should hopefully light a fire under the butts of the politicians.
    People have reached the mad-as-hell stage, with these OWS protests, but the police have cleaned it all up now. We'll see what happens next. I can't imagine what would light a fire under the Republicans, other than the smell of burning money, their money.

    Is this where things are headed, a police state to control mad-as-hell people who only want jobs and Social Security? And medical care?

    (Good topic, Sagat. We love political debate here. :) )

  • DaltheJigsawDaltheJigsaw Mountain View Veteran
    Maybe. I think it really does depend on the people. Government has done it's job, it's us the people... the 99% ... turn.
  • Who knows? I really don't care... I care plenty enough to vote when the opportunity arises, but I don't care enough to grab a sign and argue any point, or to fret about the direction of the country, economics or the human race... either we will make the best choices for our future, or we won't, but today I had a nice lunch and good conversation with some friends... life is good.

    @Dakini the fire under the Republicans is already lit (the "Tea Party"). Their intentions really are the same as many from OWS, and that is to fix the Govt to make life better for everyone. We may never learn who had the best plan, left vs right, as we continue to bash each other, ping-ponging in both directions, never fully achieving the strategy of either.

    Now for some rambling not directed towards anyone... If everyone realized that we are the same entity, only expressing different sides of ourselves, we may be less reactive by bashing each other, and truly work together to make life as enjoyable as possible for all of us. And this working as one would require us to understand that our voice may not be in sync with the voice of the majority, so at times we need to accept this and look for the joy in the journey instead of looking for opportunites for bitterness and placing blame... a dream like this may not be achievable in my life time, but this is not a prerequisite for a dream.

  • This is a very optimistic perspective. The Repubs don't really want to "fix" government, they want to whittle it down to almost nothing, and slash benefits that help people achieve a shred of decency in life. They want to privatize Social Security! Can you imagine what would have happened to people getting ready to draw on their Social Security now, if Bush had succeeded in putting it all in the stock market? Most of their SS benefits would have gone up in smoke.

    But ok, enough fuss and bother about politics.
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    Give me any point in History, where the economy was fixed to everyone's liking and general well-being.

    Then, I'll tell you.
  • Give me any point in History, where the economy was fixed to everyone's liking and general well-being.

    Then, I'll tell you.
    Yes, that is the biggest truth yet spoken here. That's like asking will society ever be fixed to everyone's general well-being. Sort answer: no.

    Form is emptiness and emptiness form. The "economy" is just one part of a human society, and as societies evolve and the push and shove of self interest brings various groups in and out of power, our economy - our way of making and distributing wealth - remains in the control of a select group. Sure, there's enough to go around, if the people who have more than they need will give up some of it. When in human history has that ever worked out? Communism tried it, but someone always has to make the rules and human nature wins in the end. They replaced one set of privileged class with another, that's all.

    The dirty secret of today is, the economy is doing great for a select group of people and those are the people paying for our elected government to stay in power. Is it sustainable? They don't care. It just makes them more eager to get more of the available wealth while the getting is good. Good times or bad, rich people do not go hungry. Cynical? When I was younger, I would have said so. Now, I've seen too much repeated to imagine we're not following the same old pattern.

  • edited November 2011
    A point in history: the post-WWII period in the US, when prosperity reigned. The people in the higher tax brackets complained, but they took for granted good roads in a great highway system, a strong infrastructure in general, the rapid expansion of the middle class, thanks in part to the G.I. Bill that provided education and affordable mortgage loans to soldiers returning from the war, and the political stability that comes with a strong middle class. Aid programs for the poor and the handicapped had full coffers. Public universities were of high quality. Though some sectors paid very high taxes by today's standards, they took for granted a functional society, and lived well in spite of high taxes. Those days of plenty and of stability are rapidly on the wane.
  • "Study hard monks for what is composite decays" ~Buddha
  • Well, fixed to the point where I'm not one of one million people between 16-24 who are now unemployed in the UK alone.

    It's that bad over here.

    Instead of fixed, how about. Not completely and utterly screwed to the point where we're on the verge of becoming a third world country.

  • I can't quite decide whether or not I think the economy will ever be fixed.
    One of the main reasons for about 99% of the wars in human history is because we can't decide on a mutually agreeable definition of "fixed". One man's fixed is another man's inequality. Those who have will always want more, and those who don't have will always want what those who have already have.

    So no, the economy isn't going to be "fixed" in your lifetime.
  • I might also add in regard to your UK third world country comment that the happiest people I've ever met have also been some of the "poorest" (by western standards). Money does not equate to happiness.
  • edited November 2011
    I might also add in regard to your UK third world country comment that the happiest people I've ever met have also been some of the "poorest" (by western standards). Money does not equate to happiness.
    This is true, it's not a platitude. But let's acknowledge that the gross income inequality that has been allowed to develop in the US (I don't know about the UK) in the last generation or so, along with many other factors, changes in tax policy, deregulation of a number of industries, etc. is pushing the country toward 3rd World status. Extreme income inequality is one of the hallmarks of 3rd World countries.

    As I've commented several times around the forum, this debacle began with Reagan. Could any of you UK members tell us what happened over your way under Thatcher? I vaguely recall they were said to have similar policies, but I have no specifics.

  • I might also add in regard to your UK third world country comment that the happiest people I've ever met have also been some of the "poorest" (by western standards). Money does not equate to happiness.
    I agree. But there's a reason why Brits refer to our country as "Rip-off Britain."

    I've never been in a well off family. But now you work crappy jobs for virtually nothing. I need to travel to work, that costs a small fortune. I could live closer to work like I used to, but that's ridiculously dangerous and the perfect to donate to crappy neighborhoods. I buy it, then some guys break in, decide if they like something and take it. It's a donation in its own twisted little way.

    Food costs too much, everything is going up in price. Electricity went from £90 to £155 for my parents in the space of a month.

    I'm not a materialist, but I go and do stuff I despise all day, just so I can afford to eat and plug in my alarm clock and fridge so I can stay nourished and awake to do another day of stuff I despise... and that's when I can find work.

    Nothing wrong with being poor. But there's not much to be happy about these days.
  • . Electricity went from £90 to £155 for my parents in the space of a month.
    What caused such a large increase in the electric bill? Was that due to an unusually large rate increase, or the onset of Fall/Winter weather, or both?

  • The economy is really bad, Sagat, and I fear that it is a downtrend in the world. I guess my advice would be to find ways to cheer up within the crappy job. Do that bullshit to the best of your ability. I think some of the same things, I am looking for a low skills entry level job currently after a few years mentally ill on disability, well hopefully I stay healthy. Good luck.
  • no.

    China took over, america is just falling and crumbling.

    all of this non-sence, all of this corruption, all of those ridiculously complicated systems that got inflated to the point of absurdity, after decades of people twisting the laws to take advantage of them, the result of decades of letting education erode (smart people are way harder to herd)...
    Now all of this non sense that was possible to create when the wind was blowing in the right direction, is just crumbling and falling.

    10-20 years and america will be worse than Poland after the war.

    it's already similar to a third world country in some part of the country (the enormous ghettos), and people got so used to the ridiculously high amount of homelessness that they don't realize it's not a normal thing for a developped country.

    Better learn Mandarin or Cantonese.

    just my 2 cents.
  • edited November 2011

    it's already similar to a third world country in some parts of the country (the enormous ghettos), and people got so used to the ridiculously high amount of homelessness that they don't realize it's not a normal thing for a developped country.
    This reminds me of accounts I've read about educated Hindus during the Victorian age, who went from India to London expecting a fabulous civilization, and were shocked by the poverty and squalor they saw. "THIS is the seat of the great British Empire??", they thought incredulously.

    The US has always had islands of 3rd and 4th-World* communities amid what used to be prosperity. Racism allowed that. Remember when South Africa was considered a modern, industrialized, wealthy nation? Then the world eventually found out how the other 90% of South Africans lived. :shake:

    *Indian reservations

  • The economy is really bad, Sagat, and I fear that it is a downtrend in the world.
    I believe the root of much of this is overpopulation, and thus an ever bigger crowd vying for ever more and bigger pieces of the same pie. The pie isn't getting any bigger, but the number of pie-coveters is. Welcome to the future.
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    edited November 2011
    Everybody loves that bouncing baby though Mountains, though in my family only 3 out of my 8 siblings has a child.

    From a buddhist perspective I think I should practice harder with my free time. On the other hand I wonder if being exposed to the problems of the world and thinking about them might even be more true to the teachings. The dichotomy of meditating or engaging in the light of the pain of the world. There is a case for either I feel.
  • The US has always had islands of 3rd and 4th-World* communities...
    *Indian reservations
    Certainly indian reservations were/are one, but there are a LOT of really poor people in the US anywhere you care to look. My mother just started a volunteer project to provide take-home food items to elementary school kids in the town where I grew up. On the outside, it's a normal, middle class small town in Michigan. Nice houses, nice schools, nice cars, etc. And yet, fully 1/3 of the kids at this elementary school qualify for inclusion in this food program because their families are at or below the poverty line. And fully 1/2 of the kids in the school qualify for free lunches for the same reason. How is that possible in America?
  • The economy is really bad, Sagat, and I fear that it is a downtrend in the world.
    I believe the root of much of this is overpopulation, and thus an ever bigger crowd vying for ever more and bigger pieces of the same pie. The pie isn't getting any bigger, but the number of pie-coveters is. Welcome to the future.
    but the pie is (or can) get bigger.

    this is a classic fallacy about economy.
    Friedman: “Most economic fallacies derive from the tendency to assume that there is a fixed pie, that one party can gain only at the expense of another.”

    i'm sure you'll find plenty of stuff online for a good explanation but here
    http://mjperry.blogspot.com/2006/12/fixed-pie-fallacy.html
    was a fairly decent overview.
  • *siblings* should include cousins in my previous post
  • Depends on what you mean by fixed.

    Economies, which are how people come together to exchange goods and services, run in cycles. Sometimes they are growing and sometimes there not. Supply and demand. It is always changing. That's to be expected.

    What we have going on now is much bigger than the normal ups and downs of the economy. It is the result of 30+ years of unchecked corporate greed. It's why, in the midst of the biggest economic slow down in 80 years, the corporations and the rich few are doing great. Balance sheets are flush with cash. The corporations are sitting on trillions of dollars. While the workers have been squeezed so hard, or lost their jobs completely through yet more downsizing, that they cannot buy stuff. Because labor is not being valued properly (due to corporate power and greed, unfair labor practices, and a lack of organized representation by the employees) it has led to a system of huge income inequality.

    In a healthy environment the govt. would step up and use it's powers of taxation, regulation, and spending to restore balance. Or to at least level the playing field so the 99% have a chance of getting a fair deal. We are not healthy.

    It is not all doom and gloom though. The Occupy movement is beginning to get the masses to wake up to what's going on.
  • I think the masses have been awake to the problem for a long time, but so mamy are busy struggling to get by, working 2 jobs, or spending afternoons in line at agencies to collect their aid, they're not available for protests. Or, they've just given up and feel hopeless.

    The pie, with careful management, can get bigger. Didn't Clinton grow the pie? Lots of jobs were created during his presidency, and the national debt was slashed.

    Mts., the statistics you give are hard to comprehend. Clearly, those families haven't lost their homes to foreclosures, so the poverty isn't due to that. We can only guess that one of the breadwinners in those households has lost a job, and the families are struggling to get by on one paycheck...?

    I'm afraid we're going to end up depressing ourselves and each other on this thread. :(
  • The economy may never be fixed - but it will adjust. Yeah - it is depressing - but then, hey - that's samsara for you.
  • edited November 2011
    The economy will never be fixed until the regulations governing the financial services industries instituted after the Depression are put back in place. Until then, there will continue to be crises requiring bank and investment brokerage bailouts using taxpayer money, a rapidly shrinking resource. Also, a more equitable tax structure is needed, as part of the "fix". Does anyone else have something to add to the "fix" list? Ah, the Euro. That, too.
  • DakiniDakini Veteran
    edited November 2011
    And sending jobs overseas. In the US, companies actually get a tax credit for doing that, there's an incentive in the system for depriving citizens of jobs and outsourcing those jobs. China, Vietnam, Bangladesh, and various Pacific island nations may make clothes and other goods cheaper, but do they make them better? The solution may mean providing more and better education for US residents, so they'll be better equipped to enter a market that's demanding a higher level of skill. This means improving instruction in the schools, and making funds available to re-train workers. Partnerships between industry and schools have worked well.
Sign In or Register to comment.