Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

Meditation Points

ThailandTomThailandTom Veteran
edited May 2012 in Meditation
Those who know me well enough on here know me and meditation haven't had a good relationship over the past few years. A few minutes ago I spent around 30 minutes meditating which happens to be the longest I have ever gone. Now a few things happened which I would like to bring up, but first I don't really feel this session has done anything much. I am still approaching meditation with a wrong intention? Anyhoo these points.

- Firstly I have noticed in meditation sometimes my heart seems to beat harder, not exactly faster just harder. It feels like it skips a beat or a beat in particular may be a thud.

- I realized how my mind wanders so easily, but this time it did not wander to what I need to do or the past/future, really random things like PG-tips, a black waterfall in my vision and some kind of purple evil grin behind a cape to name a few.

- I find focusing on the abdoman to not help keep my mind centred too well, I feel better focusin on my actual breath going in through my nose and into my lungs. Still this doesn't seem to work that well. Everytime I realize my mind has wandered I make a mental note and return.

- The pins and needles, I always get them in my legs. I change my legs around now and then and when I do I make a note to what I am doing, 'uncomfortable' 'moving legs' that kind of thing.

Comments

  • SabreSabre Veteran
    edited May 2012
    I went jogging the other day. Hadn't done any serious sports for a few years. After half a mile I was already exhausted and I felt this jogging hadn't done much. Maybe I'm aproaching it with the wrong intention? I'd like to be able to run for 10 miles. What would you advice?
  • personperson Don't believe everything you think The liminal space Veteran
    edited May 2012
    - Firstly I have noticed in meditation sometimes my heart seems to beat harder, not exactly faster just harder. It feels like it skips a beat or a beat in particular may be a thud.
    I've had that experience as well, I haven't died yet so I think its ok. It may be just a greater awareness of what happens regularly too.
    - The pins and needles, I always get them in my legs. I change my legs around now and then and when I do I make a note to what I am doing, 'uncomfortable' 'moving legs' that kind of thing.
    I switched to burmese meditation posture with my legs and that eliminated the problem of my legs falling asleep. Also the body adjusts to sitting in meditation and it gets easier.

    image
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    I usually do some walking meditation when my legs are numb. The thoughts I would just let them be there. Like clouds drifting bye. "purple cape", then settle and feel your seat and return to the breath. You might try counting to ten and then restarting when the mind wanders.

    I've meditated over ten years usually each day. The wandering thoughts will never go away. In fact meditation would not work if they did not happen. If your thoughts were under your control that would be proof that the mind is not empty of self-nature. My lama talks of the letting go of thoughts as e and when a clarity happens as Vam. eVAM.
    Something apart and letting it be.. Then VAM. Both times you can sharpen the awareness by not fighting against the mind.
  • I am kind of stuck between what I have heard or read over the years. Some people/teachers/monks say that it is about focusing your mind to a point, as Ajahn Chah would say taming the wild bull. But then people like Ajahn Brahm who ironically studied under Ajahn Chah seems to feel that it is more about letting go of everything and just sitting with what is.

    By the way @person, I already sit in that position and not the lotus, I still get pins and needles and dead legs lol... Not good.
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    It's both if you listen to Shyunru Suzuki. He said to tame cow or sheep you give it big pasture.
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    Yeah, but then you never catch the bleeder.....!

    The important is not to stress, and vary your routine.
  • BonsaiDougBonsaiDoug Simply, on the path. Veteran
    I already sit in that position and not the lotus, I still get pins and needles and dead.
    Try adjusting your cushion a bit higher, so that your knees are further down below the level of your hips.
  • - Firstly I have noticed in meditation sometimes my heart seems to beat harder, not exactly faster just harder. It feels like it skips a beat or a beat in particular may be a thud.
    That happens to me. It's not that your heart is beating harder, it's just that (for once) you're still and you can notice it. At your age, and with your recent chemical history, a slightly irregular heartbeat is nothing at all unusual. I'd be surprised if you didn't have it. There is a condition called "sinus arrhythmia" which is exactly that. Mine will skip a beat if I take in a big breath very quickly, or if I hold my breath. Nothing to be worried about in either case.
  • Invincible_summerInvincible_summer Heavy Metal Dhamma We(s)t coast, Canada Veteran


    - Firstly I have noticed in meditation sometimes my heart seems to beat harder, not exactly faster just harder. It feels like it skips a beat or a beat in particular may be a thud.
    Well I think it's just because you're noticing it more, as @mountains said. When it's quiet and you're actually sitting still enough to hear it, it probably sounds louder than you realize.
    - I realized how my mind wanders so easily, but this time it did not wander to what I need to do or the past/future, really random things like PG-tips, a black waterfall in my vision and some kind of purple evil grin behind a cape to name a few.

    - I find focusing on the abdoman to not help keep my mind centred too well, I feel better focusin on my actual breath going in through my nose and into my lungs. Still this doesn't seem to work that well. Everytime I realize my mind has wandered I make a mental note and return.
    I think it's perfectly fine for your mind to wander. But what you're doing is right (AFAIK) - just note it and return to observing arising and falling.

    I don't know if focusing on the abdomen or nostrils really matters. It's the observation of the arising and falling of sensations that matters.

    - The pins and needles, I always get them in my legs. I change my legs around now and then and when I do I make a note to what I am doing, 'uncomfortable' 'moving legs' that kind of thing.
    Do you use a cushion? If not, I'd recommend it. Some say it's a "crutch," but having a screwed-up posture and painful legs is more a hindrance to meditation than having a cushion under your butt to allow you to get a better posture, IMO.
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    Tom, some time past 2011 easter I thought something about meditation was making my eyes blink more. It was out of control distracting. But it turned out to just be just my mind noticing something that is always going on outside our notice. I also have had my heart skip a beat and my dad said that happens sometimes to him.
  • AmeliaAmelia Veteran
    The pins and needles, I always get them in my legs. I change my legs around now and then and when I do I make a note to what I am doing, 'uncomfortable' 'moving legs' that kind of thing.
    I always have this problem when I sit on a cushion. When I remove the cushion and sit more Indian or yoga style, I don't get this as frequently and I am much more comfortable. Sometimes I don't get it at all and I can sit for much longer. With a cushion, I can only sit for about ten minutes before the feeling becomes too intense to practice with. I don't know if removing the cushion will work for you, as everyone is balanced a bit differently, but maybe...
  • misecmisc1misecmisc1 I am a Hindu India Veteran
    edited May 2012
    I am kind of stuck between what I have heard or read over the years. Some people/teachers/monks say that it is about focusing your mind to a point, as Ajahn Chah would say taming the wild bull. But then people like Ajahn Brahm who ironically studied under Ajahn Chah seems to feel that it is more about letting go of everything and just sitting with what is.
    There is no irony here. Letting go of the thoughts which arise in meditation, will slowly lead to mind becoming slightly calm, which will slowly focus the mind on the object of meditation due to sati and sampajanna.
  • DairyLamaDairyLama Veteran Veteran
    I am kind of stuck between what I have heard or read over the years. Some people/teachers/monks say that it is about focusing your mind to a point, as Ajahn Chah would say taming the wild bull. But then people like Ajahn Brahm who ironically studied under Ajahn Chah seems to feel that it is more about letting go of everything and just sitting with what is.

    The approaches to meditation are many and varied, so it's good to explore them. For me it's a progression, initially some focus on the breath to calm the mind, then observation of arising and ceasing.
  • DairyLamaDairyLama Veteran Veteran
    I find focusing on the abdoman to not help keep my mind centred too well, I feel better focusin on my actual breath going in through my nose and into my lungs.
    Traditionally anapanasati is based on the wind element, so the focus should be on the breath entering and leaving the body at the nostrils. Some people focus on the movement of the abdomen, but this is one step removed.
    Or to put it more simply, the practice is called "mindfulness of breathing", not "mindfulness of the abdomen". ;)
  • CinorjerCinorjer Veteran
    edited May 2012
    @ThailandTom when you read the instructions from the many great meditators and they all seem to say something different and confuse you, then you're ready for the Great Secret of How to Meditate.

    Ready for this? Lean close. We don't want everyone to know I'm giving away the secret.

    There is no correct way to meditate. You do whatever works for you.

    That's all any of those great Masters did. There is no right and wrong way to meditate. There is no big secret technique that only they can teach that unlocks the benefits. All that is our attempt to make this seem like a huge, important and difficult tradition.

    If Lotus posture doesn't work because your legs fall asleep and distract you, then find some other posture that still keeps you sitting up fairly straight. Heck, if standing on your head feels better, do that. If only walking meditation seems to work, then start a walking meditation practice. If counting breaths isn't working, find something else to focus on. Focus on your left toe, if it helps. Get some beads, if it feels more comfortable for your hands to be doing something. Count the number of times you chew as you eat. Whatever works.

    Just keep trying different things until you find what works for you. The one that works for you is your correct way. Meditation has two rules, and only two. First, you have to be awake. Sleeping doesn't count. Second, you have to be mindful. You're meditating, not watching television.

    We'll let this be our little secret, though.

  • DairyLamaDairyLama Veteran Veteran

    There is no right and wrong way to meditate.
    But there are effective and ineffective methods, and much time and effort can be wasted if we ignore the advice of those with experience.
  • CinorjerCinorjer Veteran

    There is no right and wrong way to meditate.
    But there are effective and ineffective methods, and much time and effort can be wasted if we ignore the advice of those with experience.
    Of course! But, too often the advice ends up being "this is the way you MUST do it" because that is the way that person was taught by their own teacher. It's better to sit up straight to help with relaxed breathing, but suppose someone is bedridden with emphesyma? Then meditate on the sound of your wheezing. Be awake and be aware, that is the heart of meditation. It's taking meditation off the mat and out of the zazen hall and making it part of your life.
  • JeffreyJeffrey Veteran
    I think there is a stage where we want a way to evaluate if this is 'good' or 'bad'. Sort of to know if we are right and making progress. My guru said several things. When I was experiencing that if I recall she said the meditation instructions are hints. If you follow it literally it doesn't work so well as riding a bike you just do it you don't think ok now lean left then peddle then brake.
  • DairyLamaDairyLama Veteran Veteran
    Of course! But, too often the advice ends up being "this is the way you MUST do it" because that is the way that person was taught by their own teacher.
    Yes, that can be a problem sometimes. But if we think of meditation as a skill ( an art? ) then doesn't it make sense to take instruction from people with experience, at least in the early stages?
  • CinorjerCinorjer Veteran
    Of course! But, too often the advice ends up being "this is the way you MUST do it" because that is the way that person was taught by their own teacher.
    Yes, that can be a problem sometimes. But if we think of meditation as a skill ( an art? ) then doesn't it make sense to take instruction from people with experience, at least in the early stages?
    Yes, it does. I had the advantage of having a skilled meditation teacher and a group to help me along at the beginning. I'm not sure without that, I would have ever developed a meditative practice. I don't have near the self discipline to do something so utterly boring every day, for one thing.
  • DairyLamaDairyLama Veteran Veteran
    I don't have near the self discipline to do something so utterly boring every day, for one thing.
    :D
  • Thanks for all of the replies people, I have been a backseat sitter with this one for a while. I have learnt some things and I also realize I need a teacher or guidence more than ever. So come October I shall be heading off to that meditation class :)
  • You don't get points for meditating. That's the point.
  • FenixFenix Veteran
    @cinorjer I hope your wrong or just an unusually lazy individual, 'cause I can't attain a teacher personally
  • seeker242seeker242 Zen Florida, USA Veteran
    Pins and needles are usually an indication of improper posture. It's due to some pressure somewhere cutting off blood circulation to somewhere. With proper posture, there should not be any cutting off of circulation.

  • CinorjerCinorjer Veteran
    @cinorjer I hope your wrong or just an unusually lazy individual, 'cause I can't attain a teacher personally
    I vote for lazy. So does the Wife, by the way.
  • @seeker242 what would you suggest as a proper posture? I get pins and needles very easily, that is either because I may have some under lying heart condition or problem with arteries/veins and blood pressure, or because I constantly skip up and down with my doses of valium, and valium has many with withdrawals one being pins and needles.
  • misecmisc1misecmisc1 I am a Hindu India Veteran
    edited May 2012
    @seeker242 what would you suggest as a proper posture? I get pins and needles very easily, that is either because I may have some under lying heart condition or problem with arteries/veins and blood pressure, or because I constantly skip up and down with my doses of valium, and valium has many with withdrawals one being pins and needles.
    @thailandtom: My view: Meditation is not about sitting and doing anything, it is just letting go. The sitting posture should be comfortable, so sit in any posture as you feel comfortable - only thing which you could take into consideration is the body should be straight and back should maintain its natural curve, so that you do not feel sleepy - but the main thing is that the sitting posture should be comfortable, so that you are at ease with your body.

    just sit comfortably, close your eyes, try that your 5 senses get cut off with the external world(may be leaving the external sounds), have your natural breathing as your object of meditation, then try to be mindful of your natural breathing. whenever any thought arises in the mind, just let go of that thought and bring the attention of the mind back to the natural breathing by having sati(mindfulness) of natural breathing as your object of meditation.
  • FenixFenix Veteran
    I get pins and needles very easily... ...because I constantly skip up and down with my doses of valium, and valium has many with withdrawals one being pins and needles.
    the best posture then is the one without valium
  • No, without valium I have withdrawals, ie pins and needles as one of them. Without valium I cannot function in everyday life. Anyway, thanks guys for the information on meditation :)
  • FenixFenix Veteran
    so you gonna take them for the end remaining duration of your curt inhabitance in this world?

    what would happen anyway? after a month you would be physically non dependent. and believing you need something is only a thing you create.

    I mean what makes you so special you need valium and I don't

    but Its your life. don't let me tell you what you want

  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    Fenix - know when to quit.

  • What makes me so special I need valium? What makes somebody so special who needs incilin, o yea diabeities. I have diagnosed severe social anxiety. And sorry, what was that about a curt inhabitance? After a month of stopping valium I would be withdrawal symptom free yes, but I would have extreme anxiety. I have stopped twice and the first time I stopped for 3 months, I left my place 4 times in those 3 months. Until you can walk in somebody elses shoes, try not to make assumptions which you know little about.
  • SabreSabre Veteran
    edited May 2012
    Well, valium or no valium, I think does not matter for meditation in the aspect that the mind can detach from the body. I have had frequent meditations I did not notice my legs got really numb and could hardly walk for a while afterward. :p This is not a problem, the blood will get to the legs again afterward. But this is also a matter of training. Both body and mind need to adjust to this. In the beginning it will be a bit harder to sit.

    But just so you know you don't really have to worry about your legs and can just let them be uncomfortable if they are.
  • Yes I did not really want this thread to turn into a valium debate or my life history, it was just meant to ask some questions about meditation as I have decided to give it another shot. My left leg seems to go dead far easier than the right leg, and when I finish wow the feeling is horrid. Sometimes I do not realize they are dead like you said, but other times it is really annoying. Would it be okay to say sit in a chair but not rest my back against the chair?
  • SabreSabre Veteran
    You can sit in a chair, that's not a problem, however the body & mind will also get used to it when you practice more. Some people use a meditation bench. Also there are quite some possible positions on a cushion, for everyone another one will be more comfortable.
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    @ThailandTom, do you suppose it's ok for a person in a wheel chair to sit in a chair?
    Of course it is.
    You have accomplished masters, gurus and yogis who can sit with their ankles round their necks, for all I care.
    Some positions just do me more harm than good.
    So?
    So don't adopt them.

    Simple.
    There are no dos, do nots, musts, or must nots in any branch, sphere, practice or aspect of Buddhism.
    Why constrain yourself here?
  • I dunno federica, I just would like ot be able to break that 30 minute barrier without having these damn pins and needles. I heard sitting in a chair is okay if you have no bck support so you are more aware. The whole meditation side of buddhism is still somewhat of a mystery to me even after 3+ years..
  • misecmisc1misecmisc1 I am a Hindu India Veteran
    edited May 2012
    I dunno federica, I just would like ot be able to break that 30 minute barrier without having these damn pins and needles. I heard sitting in a chair is okay if you have no bck support so you are more aware. The whole meditation side of buddhism is still somewhat of a mystery to me even after 3+ years..
    @ThailandTom: did Buddha told in any Sutta that if we meditate more than 30 min, then at the 31st min, we will attain either peace of mind or deep concentration or Nirvana. :lol:

    remove these concepts of sitting more than 30 min from your mind, there is nothing great to happen if you ever sit for 31st min in meditation.

    meditation is not about achieving something - meditation is only about letting go of whatever is there in your mind. meditation is about training the mind, not the body. so wherever and in whichever position, you feel comfortable - just sit in that comfortable position and try to be mindful of your object of meditation - be it your natural breathing or any candle flame or anything else, but it should not be the clock which shows you how much time has passed :D
  • I have never used meditation alarms, mainly because I do not have a phone or an iphone with the ap :p But I have read many times about these barriers between 20 minutes and 30 minutes etc. But I always remember monks and the buddha saying, "do not take my word for the truth, find the truth yourself". This is one thing that attracts me to Buddhism a lot, I was a crazy angry stupid atheist before, little has changed but some things have in those 3+ years :p I just wish to meditate in a way that works for me you know.
  • SabreSabre Veteran
    Meditation does go deeper with longer sittings, so I get TT's drive. But once again, it's no problem to sit on a chair.
  • misecmisc1misecmisc1 I am a Hindu India Veteran
    I just wish to meditate in a way that works for me you know.
    @ThailandTom: So to know which meditation shall work for you - your wishing will not help, neither will somebody else be able to tell you what will work for you - only you will know what will work for you, but this will happen only if you practise meditation.
  • DairyLamaDairyLama Veteran Veteran
    But once again, it's no problem to sit on a chair.
    Yes, chairs are fine, no need to do yogic contortions. ;)

  • - Firstly I have noticed in meditation sometimes my heart seems to beat harder, not exactly faster just harder. It feels like it skips a beat or a beat in particular may be a thud.
    Hi Tom. I had the same problem some years ago. But I was stubborn and tried to ignore it. Eventually it got so bad I was having the palpitations when I _wasn't_ meditating and I was constantly aware of my heart 24/7 - which is horrible - so I stopped. The feeling of skipping a beat is a common symptom of anxiety-related palpitations.

    When I asked Ajahn Brahm about this, he said, "What are you afraid of?" After a lot contemplation I realized that what I was afraid of was that I couldn't "control" my own mind. I didn't think I was trying to control it, but I was. The trick is just to let it be and observe it. Be prepared to laugh at yourself and not take it too seriously. Start with 5 minutes of meditation and don't increase it until you can do it without the palpitations. You may find that meditating with a group works better. If all else fails, try "Buddho" instead of regular meditation.

    AFAIK, correct sitting posture is only necessary for samatha meditation, not vipassana. I use a chair all the time because of knee problems. You can still get good results.
  • misecmisc1misecmisc1 I am a Hindu India Veteran

    AFAIK, correct sitting posture is only necessary for samatha meditation, not vipassana. I use a chair all the time because of knee problems. You can still get good results.
    @orientalist: samatha and vipassana are determinations - both support each other - you cannot have one without other. there is only meditation.
  • Invincible_summerInvincible_summer Heavy Metal Dhamma We(s)t coast, Canada Veteran

    AFAIK, correct sitting posture is only necessary for samatha meditation, not vipassana. I use a chair all the time because of knee problems. You can still get good results.
    Well I think it's important to have a good sitting posture regardless of what time of meditation you choose to do, lest you create unnecessary suffering/injury to your body because you're all hunched up or something.
  • DairyLamaDairyLama Veteran Veteran
    Well I think it's important to have a good sitting posture regardless of what time of meditation you choose to do, lest you create unnecessary suffering/injury to your body because you're all hunched up or something.

    I think it's good to keep a straight back.
  • Instead of "correct" I should have said "traditional" (lotus, half-lotus, Burmese, etc).
Sign In or Register to comment.