Over the last ten years I have done a lot of letting go: news, television, novels, computer games. Recently though I was considering many of these things were distractions from the spiritual path, but they also lent my life a joyful quality, and I found I was losing my joy in life. Many things that used to give me joy, were now appearing as merely neutral. Even my morning coffee is no longer the joy it once was.
The process of letting go eventually leads one to live a life that is lean and devoid of the juicier aspects of lay life. For example, for a long time I read The Lord of the Rings every year, and I used to take great pleasure in that book, which Tolkien intended as a mythology for our times. So it now appears to me that being too drastic in letting go is also a danger on the path — we don’t have to live as monastics, even though our tendencies may take us in that direction.
I find it interesting, that when I was focussed on Buddhism all these things disappeared from my life, and now I am finding my life is too lean, and I’m seeing the need to cherish and protect the things that give me joy. That doesn’t mean I will go back to computer games, I think there are too many negatives to that, but I may broaden my reading somewhat, for starters.
Also I thought it useful to pay more attention to what gives me joy. One thing I noticed was that I feel more joyful when I am not thinking, like when I am focussed on my breath, or when I am riding my bicycle and am too engrossed in the feel of my tires on the path. When I’m busy being in the moment.
Jeroen
I think engaging with the words and speech of wise, compassionate people does have some influence on our minds.
However, teachings and words are the finger pointing to the moon and its important to engage in practice so they are able to actually get us to the destination.
person
Today - 8th of March - is International Women’s Day.
Jeroen
What was that thing about wisdom?
The wiser one gets, the more foolish one becomes.
A corollary (?):
Wisdom is earned
Stupidity is free
I think its a matter of degree. SN Goenka, who taught the likes of Jack Kornfield was a business man before becoming a spiritual teacher. Dan Harris of 10% Happier doesn't promote himself as a teacher (in fact he makes a point of saying he's not and being self depricating) but is a big promoter of spiritual and psychological work and makes a living off of it.
And to echo @marcitko in the west there isn't enough financial support generally for someone to support themselves teaching and having an income stream from it is often necessary.
But in the example you give, it does seem like this person is more than trying to be of service in the spiritual arena, using spirituality as a means to earn a living.
Though I have a "wide net" sort of attitude. I'm fine with people using spirituality in a shallow way, it can bring more people in. It will offer some level of more superficial benefit to a greater number of people, that might not otherwise have met with the teachings, than only having a pure offering. And for some it will be an entry point to the deeper end of the pool.
person
I am wary of those that promote spirituality as a means to business or material advancement, thus making spirituality secondary and merely a means to a wordly end.
That said, some or even many seem to believe that being a businesperson somehow disqualifies one from being spiritual. I don't think that's true. Lay people are not monks and need to support themselves + it can be just another arena for practice. I know of many higly advanced or even realized people who just so happened to be businespeople.
As persons, we’re responsible to culture and to others, and we are constantly changing, open-ended phenomena, not isolated, self-existent phenomena. We are part of a spatial, temporal, and social complex, not standing outside of it in a dualistic relation.
Jay L. Garfield, “To Be or Not to Be”
Sometimes compassion will arise spontaneously, like the clouds parting to reveal the blue sky. At other times we may have to make a conscious effort, which is a bit more like imagining what the blue sky looks like, even when it’s obscured by clouds.
Andy Puddicombe, “10 Tips for Living More Mindfully”
Jeffrey
I see them as guiding lights for behaviour in daily life. They can inspire, even when they choose not to be teachers. I also think Bodhisattvas show up in many unexpected places, especially when circumstances are difficult.
I would even say, anyone you see being acclaimed as a Bodhisattva in a religious setting is unlikely to truly be one.
Jeroen
I remember reading about hot boredom and then cool boredom as legitimate or charted parts of the meditation path. Try not to think "I mistakenly had the meditation that isn't supposed to happen". Maybe get curious about the boredom? or say "Chaat" and then return to the breath
I'm taking a break from meditating as part of my usual cycles. It will call me again I have experience of my cycles spiral learning
Jeffrey
With breath meditation, my understanding is that all manner of thougts will arise and our practice is the same: gently return to the breath. It should be the same with body scans, gently return to scanning the body.
The mind will conjure up endless tricks to suck us in. 'What does boredom during meditation mean?' is just one such example.