@JohnCobb you're right that it's not always a great idea to be the person in the room being sanctimonious, and sometimes you just can't walk away. There isn't just one right answer. Sometimes the best thing you can do is to keep quiet and take note of the fact that you're learning about some people that could benefit from being treated with more compassion. Later, you can do a Metta meditation and direct your compassionate thoughts towards those folks. I'm a materialist so I personally don't think that this results in anything except for a positive change in your own outlook, both towards yourself and the other people you're thinking of, but for me that's been cathartic.
When people talk trash around me, I try to find a good place to bring up the fact that everyone is a product of their life experience, and hurtful behavior is usually a symptom of trauma- which means that the most reasonable target of someone's annoyance should be the lack of compassion in the world instead of the victims of it.
When all else fails, and you can't remember the right Buddhist list for reference when choosing your next action, use this handy list I came up with for emergencies:
1. Don't be an asshole
2. If someone says you've been an asshole, really listen to them and express your regret and your intention to enact less assholery in the future.
3. Mindfulness mediation can make #'s 1 and 2 far more achievable.
ScottPen
@Ren_in_black said:
What the duck are you on about?
Don't mind him, he's quackers. You wait until his Psychiatrist sends him his bill. He'll have to dig into his nest egg... but he's harmless. Just a great big platypussy.
federica
@Ren_in_black said:
@FoibleFull said:
If you are not fully aware of the inescapability of discontent/suffering in your life, you aren't going to care about fixing the issue.True but I think people hear about something being inescapable and decide they'd rather not have full awareness, better to reject it at Point A and take a different road altogether.
Maybe modern translations should include additional modern phrasing, such as "But hear me out..."
I think when we see the 1st NT as an inescapable truth we see the other NTs as separate truths instead of one remedy with four steps. For me personally, it always felt as if the Buddha is saying that in life there is dukkha/suffering, not that life is all suffering. After all, he had supposedly found the way out without physically passing away. So then at the time of the teaching, all life was not suffering since he himself had realised its cessation.
The Four Noble Truths, instead of one Truth with 4 parts ... comes from the oral tradition of Buddhism. With few people being able to read, they had to memorize. So Buddhism is FULL of the 4 This, the 8 That, the 81 Whatevers, etc. They like to list things off, these Buddhists. They will pick someone apart into hundreds of pieces and then memorize it.
I guess literate people get lazy, mentally.
As for understanding the 1st Noble Truth until you DO see this operating in your life, not as an intellectual concept but as an experience or realization .. the next 3 Truths don't seem very important. If you are not fully aware of the inescapability of discontent/suffering in your life, you aren't going to care about fixing the issue.
Well, the Buddha once said ehipassiko, come and see for yourself. What he meant by that is that any teaching that you come across should be examined to see for yourself if you could determine the truth of it, and set aside if you could not. Those with a grounding in science often find this a very comfortable position, which explains its appeal to the western mind.
Often the response to continuing appeals to ehipassiko is a discussion on sraddha, trust and faith in the teachings, which early on in one’s path in Buddhism certainly has a place, and perhaps later as well. Once you have been immersing yourself in it for a little while things start to ‘click’ and you start to see for yourself which things are true for you. The ongoing process of discovery and verification of the teachings is supposed to build an unshakable certainty that the Buddha’s path as described is true and correct.
Secular Buddhism is this discussion taken to an extreme, shedding the supernatural elements of the teachings that cannot be proven and putting them aside. That leaves a focus on the Four Noble Truths, that unhappiness is here, and the Noble Eightfold Path, to Nirvana and enlightenment in this life, as well as disciplines such as mindfulness.
Ultimately there is little difference between secular Buddhism and other types of Buddhism. It is just that a type of Buddhism which places a heavy emphasis on reincarnation may allow people to focus on a path of many lives that ultimately leads to enlightenment, allowing one to slack in this life because it is just a small section of the path. Secular Buddhism places you squarely before the task of trying to achieve enlightenment in this life.
Anyway that’s just my view of it… if it sounds appealing you might want to read some of the books of Stephen Batchelor, who more or less started this ball rolling with his autobiographical Confessions of a Buddhist Atheist.
Jeroen
@Kerome thanks for the thoughtful comment. When taking part in some other online communities, I've been surprised at the scorn I've experienced for the secular approach. It's frequently dressed up as "protecting the dhamma against the spreading of wrong view" or "call it what you want but it's not Buddhism."
It's not important to me what other people call my spiritual practice. I'm not a Buddhist anyway. I'm a person who's trying to reduce suffering, and who's walking that path in the dhamma.
ScottPen
It’s possible to say “you are my brother” without letting the other person walk all over you. It’s possible to be generous with your time and with your heart without losing your financial stability. Sometimes it is necessary to be strong with another person, to prevent their bad habits from hijacking your good impulses.
I was recently sent this, which seems to fit:

federica
I’d suggest you listen to the experts. We are just humble lay people who are in no position to give you medical advice.
Sadhu 🙏
Bunks
A cow moose and two calves visited this morning and sampled a variety of my wife's plantings. Last night Tribble the dog was roaring at ghosts at 3 in the morning, but slept through this morning's visitation -


Fosdick
I’m working at creating a way to unify Thai forest Buddhism and Chinese Pure Land. But they seem to be two ends of the spectrum 
One has us focus on the present moment while one is more geared to what happens after death.
I guess in some ways they’re the perfect mix right?
Thai Forest Pure Land hehe 😜
Bunks