Here's something I wrote somewhere elsewhere specifically for white people. It's not really meant for comments/discussion, but only for consideration (I won't address them at any rate).
The irony of the prophet is that they see futures and truths that the majority of us refuse to acknowledge and believe to our own detriment, yet they cannot do anything but preach them despite being ignored or reviled by the very world they're trying to help. They are compelled to do so by something inside of them they cannot ignore, by a love for their fellow brethren and a deep compassion for the suffering and oppression the poor and marginalized experience due to the existence of greed, hatred, and ignorance in the hearts of those who rule over them. With their words, they lay bare the flaws and sins of society and try to show us another path, one leading to humility and justice and reconciliation. And oftentimes, those words and their prescriptions are a challenge and a threat to the rich and powerful, who profit at the expense of the least among us; and their witnessing to the truth puts their lives in danger.
There are prophets everywhere in the world and in every walk of life; and if we could only learn to listen them, our world would be a different place. They tell us the difficult things we may not wish to hear but are necessary. They warn us of the consequences that we don't wish to face up to if we don't change our ways. And if we heeded their words more often, perhaps the 'moral arc of the universe' would be a little less long and bend even more towards justice than it historically does. But more often than not, it seems, prophets are only appreciated by society far into the future, when their words ring loud and true and their warnings have unfortunately all come to pass. Only then are their words recognized. I think one of those prophets was MLK Jr., who spoke out against the evils of racism, poverty, and war. And in that witnessing, he also spoke out against capitalism and those who criticized the ways oppressed people fought their oppression. In 1963, for example, MLK famously wrote:
First, I must confess that over the last few years I have been gravely disappointed with the white moderate. I have almost reached the regrettable conclusion that the Negro's great stumbling block in the stride toward freedom is not the White Citizen's Council-er or the Ku Klux Klanner, but the white moderate who is more devoted to 'order' than to justice; who prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace which is the presence of justice; who constantly says 'I agree with you in the goal you seek, but I can't agree with your methods of direct action;' who paternalistically feels he can set the timetable for another man's freedom; who lives by the myth of time and who constantly advises the Negro to wait until a 'more convenient season.'
They were powerful words then, and unfortunately, they still carry a great deal of weight today. I've been thinking a lot about those words while reading things like our mayor's response to the protests, watching the mainstream news coverage, and contemplating the role white people have historically played in the oppression of black people; and the way I see it, you're either on the side of the black community or you're not. It's that simple. Black people in the US have literally suffered generations of oppression and racism in this country, from slavery to segregation and lynching to modern-day redlining, mass incarceration, and police violence. They have been patient enough for justice. Beyond patient. They have spent generations peacefully protesting and working within the system (and most still do). They have spent generations making their case for true equality and reparations for what they have had to endure. They have pleaded generation after generation for white society to see their plight, hear their cries, and to act. And for generations, those cries have mostly fallen on deaf ears or else have been answered by piecemeal reforms here and there, and often only after sustained pressure and civil unrest. Restorative justice has always remained a dream just out of reach.
That's why MLK said that the riot was the language of the unheard. Voices can only cry out for so long before they go hoarse and the generations of sadness, anger, and frustration start to boil over and become expressed in different ways, especially in reaction to watching yet another member of their community be killed—watching it over and over again on the news and social media and seeing how nobody stopped it and how nobody was held accountable, and listening to all the excuses for why his murder was justified or unavoidable. Can you imagine that level of sadness, anger, and frustration? And so just like Chicago in 1919, Harlem in 1964, Watts in 1965, Detroit in 1967, LA in 1992, Ferguson in 2014, Baltimore in 2015, etc., we have Minneapolis et al. in 2020.
Of course, seeing beyond our privilege and through the propaganda and fairytale narratives we've been told our whole lives about the American Dream is a difficult task. We essentially have to be deprogrammed. But the hard truth of the matter is, if you're on the side of the police and those who talk about order and the rule of law and not about the scourge of racism and the terror that the police are for black and other nonwhite individuals (as well as the poor, homeless, mentally ill, etc.), you're ultimately on the side of institutionalized racism, classism, and oppression. And as well-meaning as many may be, I think MLK's criticism of the 'white moderate' is equally as valid for white moderates (and moderates and centrists in general) who today say that they support the black community and believe black lives matter yet criticize their methods or language or cynicism towards politicians, the police, and white society itself. His words were directed squarely at those who were in opposition to anyone fighting for immediate justice for black people (and other marginalized groups) with various means of direct action, because their opposition, in the name of civility and order, ultimately helped to maintain things as they were, as untenable as they were.
And MLK's advice is just as valid today as it was in 1963: Don't fall for the myth of time and waiting for a "more convenient season." The time is always right for justice, whether it's justice for BIPOC, justice for the poor, justice for immigrants, justice for women, justice for the LGBTQ community, justice for those with physical or mental disabilities, or justice for the planet. And we shouldn't be afraid to pick a side, because as Howard Zinn used to say, "You can't be neutral on a moving train." Silence is complicity, even if it's inadvertent.
Nevertheless, it's easy to simply say that black lives matter, but now it's up to us to prove that they matter by doing what we can to defend and support those lives. And to do that, one of the things that must be done is to help force the radical restructuring of our world — materially, spiritually, and everything in between — while also standing in solidarity with everyone out in the streets right now. We have to help forge a future without racism. We created the problem, so it's definitely on us to help solve it.
Time after time after time, police engage protesters with violence time after time after time they provoke it with the killing of unarmed black men, women, and children. Our mayors are complicit. Our legislators are complicit. Our governors are complicit. Our courts are complicit. Corporations are complicit. And our federal government is complicit. Where do they get their money? Where do they get their weapons and tech? Where do they get their orders and immunity? So how can we expect all of these bricks in a larger systemic wall of inequality and violence to do what is right and give us justice when they've failed to do so for generations?
The police protect the socioeconomic order, an order that leaves many at the mercy of markets and predatory corporations and systemic injustice. They protect property, wealth, and white privilege. How many times have journalists reported on this? How many times has this been addressed in city councils? How many promises have we been given at podiums by our leaders that change is coming? So where are they? They're out in the streets right now. The change is coming with the power of everyday people rallying around a common cause, confronting the police and the system they protect. Change is coming because of our solidarity, our numbers, our direct actions, and our righteous anger at inequality, injustice, and oppression.
Jason
@David said:
@person said:
There are pleasant things in life but they don't have an essence of happiness to them. The more we have of them we don't get happier. I find the most pleasant moment of a dessert is the first bite, a pint of ice cream is still pretty pleasant but after the second it starts to become unsatisfactory, the third and fourth unpleasant and by the fifth I would classify it as outright suffering. Same with a nice piece of music, it is good once or twice but playing a song 24 hours a day is a form of torture.Of course we don't live like that, we get a taste of one small pleasure then jump to another and another, taking a little bite and moving on before it changes. We construct our lives so that we have as constant a stream of pleasant hits as we need. All that seeking leads to building up a muscle of craving, the experience of craving is one of suffering compared to the experience of the absence of craving.
We can put our efforts into building a world where we can always have a hit of pleasure to keep us topped off or we can let go of our craving and find an inner sort of happiness that is present when our craving subsides.
There is pleasure when a sore is scratched, But to be without sores is more pleasurable still. Just so, there are pleasures in worldly desires, But to be without desires is more pleasurable still. ~Nagarjuna
Sorry to remark on the same post twice but it just got me to thinking and I have to ask the obvious question.
If you could, would you wipe the first taste of ice cream and the perceptions that arose with the interaction from your experience?
Well, for starters I'm a worldly person. I don't deserve @Bunks sadhu, I'm mostly just parroting teachings I've heard that are more common in Tibetan Buddhism than in western Dharma. I have a pretty big sweet tooth and enjoy the company of family and friends.
I'm more pointing to a point of practice rather than a set of rules on how we should behave. What I think you and @Kerome are maybe missing is the pleasant spiritual feeling that arises in the absence of craving and are mainly noticing the restrictiveness or asceticism. For example, how is your experience right now of the absence of a heroin addiction? You probably aren't even aware generally but if I could suddenly plop one down on you you'd find your current state relatively quite pleasant.
For me what it does is direct the way I structure and direct my life. I don't expect to find lasting happiness by arranging regular spa days, family picnics and friendly happy hours. I look to spiritual practice for that. Not only will they not fulfill me but the more I rely on them the greater my craving for them grows and the larger the hole I'm trying to fill grows.
In other words I look to rearrange my mind to find peace and happiness more than attempting to rearrange the world. The world never quite works out the way you want and is always slipping away.
person
One thing that may be interesting is to investigate if what, if anything, is satisfactory in a fundamental sense and explore how our grasping at what we find to be pleasurable/satisfactory ends in happiness, suffering, etc. The Buddha certainly never taught that there isn't pleasure or happiness, so what may he have been getting at with his teachings on kamma, dukkha, etc.? For example, something may give us immediate pleasure and happiness so we think it's good and indulge, but what about hours or even years later? Does that experience change? If so, how and why? These are things we are encouraged to explore. While many see the teachings in places like MN 61 to be simplistic, they actually encourage us to do a lot of contemplative work over a long period of time.
Jason
I just found out there's a case in the retirement home I'm going back to fulltime. It's been a bit over a week and still only the one case and I don't start til the 15th.
Still feel a bit spooked but I pretty much have to do it. The reason I got out of it was because my headaches and tinnitus started up at the same time and it really screwed me up for a while. That and here, it is a big ordeal trying to snag a fulltime gig.
At least until the virus came around. Now people are running from the job and suddenly, private homes want to obtain fulltime staff since going from one home to another is a big problem.
There were no cases when I took the job a week ago and now there is 1.
No regrets but I'm just a wee bit more weary of the whole idea than I was, lol.
Oh well, that's the nature of the beast, right?
There are pleasant things in life but they don't have an essence of happiness to them. The more we have of them we don't get happier. I find the most pleasant moment of a dessert is the first bite, a pint of ice cream is still pretty pleasant but after the second it starts to become unsatisfactory, the third and fourth unpleasant and by the fifth I would classify it as outright suffering. Same with a nice piece of music, it is good once or twice but playing a song 24 hours a day is a form of torture.
Of course we don't live like that, we get a taste of one small pleasure then jump to another and another, taking a little bite and moving on before it changes. We construct our lives so that we have as constant a stream of pleasant hits as we need. All that seeking leads to building up a muscle of craving, the experience of craving is one of suffering compared to the experience of the absence of craving.
We can put our efforts into building a world where we can always have a hit of pleasure to keep us topped off or we can let go of our craving and find an inner sort of happiness that is present when our craving subsides.
There is pleasure when a sore is scratched, But to be without sores is more pleasurable still. Just so, there are pleasures in worldly desires, But to be without desires is more pleasurable still. ~Nagarjuna
person
A suspected Covid-19 male patient is lying in bed in the hospital, wearing an oxygen mask over his mouth and nose. A nurse appears and gives him a partial sponge bath.
"Nurse,"' he mumbles from behind the mask, "are my testicles black?"
Embarrassed, the young nurse replies, "I don't know, Sir. I'm only here to wash your upper body and feet."
He struggles to ask again, "Nurse, please check for me. Are my testicles black?"
Concerned that he might elevate his blood pressure and heart rate from worrying about his testicles, she overcomes her embarrassment and
pulls back the covers.
She raises his gown, looks very closely and says, "There's nothing wrong with them, Sir. They look fine."
The man slowly pulls off his oxygen mask, and says very slowly,
"Thank you very much. Now listen very, very, closely:
"Are - my - test - results - back?"
person
@Kerome
This theme can be found throughout most of your postings. In Zen we would probably call this the Koan of your daily life. It describes an issue that permeates the foundation of a life, gets constantly reflected back at you in gross & subtle forms and no matter where you go it remains almost beyond your capacity to address.
Everyone has their own koan and usually we can't even directly see it for how close we are to it, but beyond our own conditioned behaviors, its wake becomes apparent.
If this writer, who has never actually met you, is correct, until the solution to this issue gets given a greater priority than everything else in your life, you will remain uncomfortably subject to what Ajahn Chah calls life's instability and unsatisfactoriness .
At least that what the world looks like from my small “somewhat rude” corner of Zen.
I always appreciate how often your questions, spiritually till the earth on this site.
how
There's a bug in the post formatter. When the bug gets triggered enough times in a discussion, PHP crashes, thus the 502 Gateway error.
I attempted to upgrade Vanilla on Sunday and succeeded only in breaking everything, but I did confirm the upgrade fixes the bug. Unfortunately I was forced to roll back to the old bugged version for the moment until I have time to pursue the upgrade again.
Linc