Ok, bucket list item crossed off. Tonight I was 4th row right in front of YoYo Ma!! ..with the Memphis Symphony Orchestra! My God, watching that man play the cello in person was breathtaking! 🎻.
Vastmind
It seems to me that Buddhism does have some understanding of dysfunction in the mind…
It seems to agree with psychology and psychiatry that part of the spectrum of human experience is covered by insanity and dysfunction. This seems true on the scale of nations as well as individuals.
To me it feels like spirituality is in the first instance about uncovering what is sane in us, what is beneficial to our well-being. Only after we have done that can we talk about lofty goals like the Bodhisattva ideal.
Food for thought?
Jeroen
@Jason said:
@Ren_in_black said:
If so, is this written somewhere, or is it something that's been sort of understood through the logic of the teachings?This particular idea is not found in Pali Canon and is associated more with the Jain’s view or karma, e.g., see MN 101 and MN 136 and Thanissaro Bhikkhu’s study guide on the topic.
As far as past actions, there are teachings that present skillful actions can help mitigate the results of previous unskillful actions but cannot fully eliminate them (SN 42.8). In other words, there are some consequences that may arise even if one does a lot to counteract them. And awakening changes the logic, although one can still experience the effects of past actions, but their relationship to them will be different and the creation of new karmic results is no longer an issue. St. Maximus explains it well, I think, in Opuscula theologica et polemica (albeit from a Christian perspective), when he writes, “A perfect nature has no need of choice [i.e., intentional actions or karma], for it knows naturally what is good. Its freedom is based on this knowledge." And the noble eightfold path is what can help us get there (SN 35.145).
Jason
@Ren_in_black said:
If so, is this written somewhere, or is it something that's been sort of understood through the logic of the teachings?
This particular idea is not found in Pali Canon and is associated more with the Jain’s view or karma, e.g., see MN 101 and MN 136 and Thanissaro Bhikkhu’s study guide on the topic.
Jason
@Jeroen said:
@Jason said:
@Jeroen said:
@Jason said:
seeing a psychiatristThe neurodivergent movement seems to be having a bit of a moment, that is for sure. But my experience with psychiatrists is that they are generally more interested in prescribing you pills than in genuine mental health. Music and Buddhism have done me more good in recent years than anything else.
Glad to hear it. In my case, music and Buddhism weren’t quite enough 🤷♂️
I found an investigation into my views and their origins to be helpful. Generally the stronger the opinions that you hold, the more difficult it is to live as kindness, softness, mellowness. Living with one’s being in that space means being more forgiving, holding fewer grudges, and acts as a general protective measure against much mental ill health.
Hence I practice metta even for bodhi Trump.
I think it all depends on what the opinions are as opposed to how strong one holds to them. I know the general attitude of Buddhism is to relinquish views, but some views are skillful and useful and shouldn’t be abandoned before they’re no longer useful.
Holding strong opinions on the efficacy of the principles of Buddhism (especially the precepts, teachings on interdependence, and the four brahmaviharas) has helped to make me a kinder, more compassionate, and easy to talk to person. The same goes for my political opinions. That’s why I’m able to room and treat a patient no matter who they are or what they believe, and every one feels comfortable enough to share their thoughts with me. I’ve had people go off about vaccines being a scam and how I should vote for Trump because he’ll make things good again and others who’d say the opposite. They all feel comfortable enough to share these things with me, and I treat them all the same because I care about them as people.
My own suffering partially stems from childhood trauma and some neurodivergent issues, but the majority of it stems from systemic issues and the external pressures they exert upon my life, not so much my opinions. And while Buddhism has helped me greatly over the years, there are some things that it hasn’t and I’m open to exploring other tools to help. And for mental health issues, I’ve found that finding the right therapist can go a long way towards helping one heal and overcome things that prevent them from moving forward.
Jason