@person said:
Without any real depth of experience with them myself I conceptualize shamatha as a process where one slows down mental phenomenon to a point where it becomes much easier to see through them. Vipassana I see as a process where one becomes better at seeing through things where effectively mental phenomenon slow down.
Traditionally, time dilation only happens in the deep dhyānas and their dhyānāntaras (the near-dhyānas that go in-between and before the proper dhyānas).
In Mahāyāna Buddhism, śamatha is first. Śamatha, or zhǐ, is literally "calming" or "stopping." The śamatha must be stabized in either the dhyānāntara of the first dhyāna or the first dhyāna itself. Vipaśyanā/vipassanā then uses the vitarkavicāra (discriminating mind) of the first dhyāna or lower. Higher dhyānas have different vipaśyanās, such as the vipaśyanā of the "body of rapture" experienced in the third dhyāna. The language of "body of rapture" is from the Dharmaguptaka Dīrghāgama. The rest of the presentation here is according to the Tiāntāi tradition:
When the body comes in contact with a first tactile sensation, such as movement, and becomes a condition, this is vitarka ["examination"]. When the mind makes finer distinctions concerning the eight tactile sensations and its ten associated qualities, this is called vicāra ["reflection"]. Rejoicing now at attaining that which had not yet been attained in the past is called prīti ["joy"]. Calm pleasure in these attainments is called sukha ["bliss"]. Such quiescence is called ekāgratā ["one-pointedness"]. The five constituents are all the essence of samādhi. The five constituents arise together. It is like a mallet hitting a temple bell; there are differences, in that at first the sound is rough, but gradually it becomes finer. The five constituents are also like this. At first, there is abundant contact with the aspect of examination, but this does not hinder the others, such as reflection. If examination is strong, then reflection is not yet complete; when examination ceases, reflection becomes clear. Joy is already present from the beginning, and when reflection ceases, the constituent of joy is perfected. Bliss is already present from the beginning, though that bliss may not yet be full; when joy ceases, then bliss is perfected. One-pointedness is already present from the beginning in the movement of the other four constituents, but now when bliss ends, one-pointedness is perfected.
(Ven Zhiyi, Mahāśamathavipaśyanā T1911.118b20 abridged)
Following Ven Zhiyi's schema, the first dhyāna is a perfection of vitarkavicāra. With the cessation of vitarkavicāra, there is the perfection of bliss/joy. With the cessation of bliss/joy, there is the perfection of rapture. With the cessation of rapture, there is the perfection of one-pointedness. As the Platform Sūtra says, "The one-pointed heart is the mother of all samādhi."
I am not a dhyānin though. I hover at trying to stabilize the dhyānāntara of the first dhyāna. Perhaps I have succeeded before, I have had some interesting experiences, but the śamatha is not stabilized: I cannot enter the state at will and stay there at will. So we know it is not a stabilized śamatha and even less an authentic dhyāna.
Don't give up on śamatha. According to many narratives, it is impossible to do vipaśyanā without stabilized śamatha.
@Kerome said:
@Shoshin1 said:
One can not be conditioned into letting go one can only become aware of the benefits of not holding on, and from what "I" gather an enlightened mind is an unfettered mind...There is something to the idea of becoming utterly relaxed as a path to enlightenment. However, if you do then you become kind of floppy. There is also viriya, energy that causes one to do whole some things, and thīna-middha or sloth-torpor, one of the five hindrances.
Methinks there is a Middle Way even in relaxation and in letting go.
This reminds me of my thread 'Growth through joy'. There has to be an internal motivation. And to make any kind of progress on this path then that motivation needs to be consistent and iron-clad. I've tried to 'let go of everything' but I ended up letting go of my practice too, and found myself drifting around aimlessly and flabbily.
I think the path is of stages. And what is correct for our current stage might not be so for the next one. We need to be flexible and adaptable. Always a 'beginners mind'. Just because something has worked for us does not mean it will continue to work for us.
When I first started the path I was very hard on myself. I was relentless in working on eradicating certain traits. This was very helpful at that stage because the harm I was doing through those traits was much more than the harm I was doing to myself through being hard on myself.
However, later down the path when those traits had been mostly eradicated, being hard on myself was causing more harm than it was preventing, and so I had to learn how to be more gentle with myself, which in turn allowed me to express more positive traits that I was overlooking because my mindset was so conditioned to only see the bad in myself.
The ultimate 'letting go' is not helpful at other stages. It's too hard for a beginner on the path to understand, and it will likely have counter-productive results. We can practice letting go gradually whilst retaining a firm and disciplined commitment to our chosen practice. And when that firm and disciplined commitment to our practice is counter-productive rather than productive - which I suspect can only be pre-enlightenment - then we can let go of that too.
It is a strange path. It is like we are untangling a giant knot to discover the rope, only to untangle the knot and realise that the rope was there all along. And yet, untangle we must.
My son and his wife who have been living in New Zealand for a year were just given an eight month extension of their stay. Thank you New Zealand for not forcing them to return to the US where covid-19 runs rampant and insanity reigns.
@Kerome said:
Recently I have been interacting with a Dutch Buddhist who is also a follower of anarchism (which is also referred to as libertarianism in some parts of the world), and I have found it interesting to consider what the meeting of the two might mean. Personally I’ve never been that interested in political philosophy, and the whole idea of class struggle is something that I have rarely contemplated.I’ve always thought that if you decline to be fitted into other people’s compartments for easy identification, you can consider yourself more of an individual, more free in a way. Which is why I don’t apply isms to myself, because they always seem to come with certain expectations. One of the main things I have learnt from Buddhism is that a lot of the movement towards freedom comes from dissolving ones own previously held convictions, the restrictions we have placed on ourselves.
Of course this is also about identity, a lot of people define themselves by being a member of certain groups. This then brings in attachment to the groups ideals and goals, which then starts to stir the emotions. It seems a set of behaviours which is not really conducive to the path...
How do you feel about identity and being part of movements? How does it work with your Buddhism?
There are many ways to approach this, and while I wasn't going to comment, I suppose I could add a few things since I suppose this is the kind of area people most expect me to weigh in on. One is, you're not necessarily more "free" simply by refusing to identify as one thing or another, or by refusing to be engaged in certain things, such as politics. For one, you can still be controlled by material and ideological forces whether or not you adopt a certain identity or refuse to consciously engage in politics. Often times, these things are ubiquitous and omnipresent and conditions us without us even realizing it. And where Buddhism can be useful is in helping us to discover that conditioning. As for identities themselves, the expectations or lack thereof are entirely up to us.
For example, me being a socialist and Marxist is due to the fact that I think everyone deserves to own their labour and have a more equitable share of the wealth their labour creates and that Marxism offers a useful method of analysis to understand the logic of capitalism and the shape of our society in an effort to transform it. Conversely, me being a Buddhist is due to the fact that I see a great deal of wisdom and utility in the Buddha's words and practices when it comes to understanding our minds and how to transform them. I find these approaches complimentary. And it can be useful to use labels such as socialist, Marxist, or Buddhist to give people an idea of what my ideas are and what I'm all about. Of course, there's a danger of attaching to those ideas and identities and become slaves to them, but Buddhism has helped me to avoid the worst of that so I can use the world's designations, expressions, ways of speaking without grasping them.
In essence, an identity for me is something that's useful. The goal of Buddhism (at least to me) isn't to become devoid of personality and the total death of any sort of convention self, but the ability to use those things skillfully so that they eventually cease to contribute to our experience of suffering. Self-identification is useful to a point. As Thanissaro Bhikkhu puts it, "In the areas where you need a healthy sense of self to act skillfully, it's wise to maintain that sense of self." And when it's no longer useful, you let it go. We can't really function as a human being without some level of selfing involved. We need some level of understanding, empathy, and motivation. And to communicate and act effectively in the world, we need the ability to foster a healthy sense of self. We are a social species, after all, and much of our success stems from our degree of socialization and cooperation.
Of course, it is up to each of us to figure out what works best. To figure out what we believe in and desire to work towards. And our unique biology and experiences will help to inform that. Mine have lead me to see that we need to work on both our mental and material well-being in order to lessen the suffering we experience as a species and as individuals since the material basis of society acts as the foundation for our psychological potentials and experiences, helping to shape them. Yes, there is freedom in letting go of what isn't ours. And some of us may be at a spiritual level where we are completely free from those conditionings and attachments and the control they exert over us. But most of us are not, and not everyone is up to training their minds to accept and weather any material condition no matter how painful, so it benefits society to try and make those material conditions as conducive to happiness as possible.
Think of Maslow's hierarchy. If people's basic physiological needs aren't met, how can they hope to work on their safety and security? And without both of those needs being met, how can they develop things like love and sense of belonging? And if they are unable to develop those kinds of intimate connections, how can they ever be expected to develop self-esteem and self-actualization? It would be exceedingly difficult. And I think suttas such as DN 5 make the case that, in general, people can't be expected to be happy, law-abiding people when their material needs aren't meant. In the story that the Buddha tells, the king wants to eradicate the thieves and barbarians causing crime and violence within his kingdom by imprisonment, banishment, or death, but his wise advisor says:
Rather, here is a plan, relying on which the barbarian obstacle will be properly uprooted. So let the king provide seed and fodder for those in the realm who work in farming and raising cattle. Let the king provide funding for those who work in trade. Let the king guarantee food and wages for those in government service. Then the people, occupied with their own work, will not harass the realm. The king’s revenues will be great. When the country is secured as a sanctuary, free of being harried and oppressed, the happy people, with joy in their hearts, dancing with children at their breast, will dwell as if their houses were wide open.’
So here is another area where my identity as a Buddhist, socialist, and Marxist coincides and interacts, reinforcing one another and hopefully helping me to avoid some of the issues that can come with grasping those identities too hard. And for the past 10 years or so, I've found no issues with such an approach. Others have found their own happiness and contentment with doing the opposite and eschewing any sort of political or "worldly" action, retreating into their own internal and external solitude. So I can't say which is best, only that the former has worked for me because I've found myself unable to do nothing in the face of the suffering of others. If my freedom depends upon the privation and suffering of others, it's not a freedom I deem worth having.
That may put me into a bondage of sorts to those identities and ideas, but at least it's a form of bondage born out of compassion. And this discussion has reminded of why I was drawn to both the bodhisattva ideal and the life and works of Eugene Debs. The former vows, "Suffering beings are numberless, I vow to liberate them all. Attachment is inexhaustible, I vow to release it all. The gates to truth are numberless, I vow to master them all. The way of awakening is supreme, I vow to realize." And the latter stated, "Years ago I recognized my kinship with all living beings, and I made up my mind that I was not one bit better than the meanest on earth. I said then, and I say now, that while there is a lower class, I am in it, and while there is a criminal element I am of it, and while there is a soul in prison, I am not free." Our freedoms are all interconnected.
Jason
I’m an advocate of what TNH has brought to the table. Essentially, he has taken complex and often (for the lay Westerner) impenetrable doctrine and transmitted it in a fashion that is simple and as a consequence, more easily understood. His explanations around Interconnectedness, emptiness and reality are probably the most beautifully written and easily graspable that I’ve seen.
So for me, I dig him. The focus is upon the Buddha’s simple messages, practical living and kindness, rather than complex understanding of the written doctrine. His understanding is there, but he puts things simply for us. Many will also appreciate him. Along with the Dalai Lama, probably the most responsible for the appreciation of Buddhism that has grown in the West.
In terms of his books :- I’m currently reading The art of living (which covers all of the above and some good explanations of never born/never die), the Heart of the Buddha’s teaching is great re the core principles of Buddhism and their application. I particularly also like ‘Silence’ I find it a very calming read.
In truth, you can’t go wrong with anything by TNH.
Alex
Possibly some zen!
A minds acquisition & understanding of a perfect description of zen is limited by that same minds habituated need to value a sense of self before others.
For this reason, many descriptions of zen are given some mystical inferences that are frankly just lures to attract one in before its following hook.
In the actual practice of Zen, when the minds illusionary fiefdom starts to crumble, that mind gets to share in some understanding with it's other fellow senses, of every thing that was formally hidden by it's own self-centeredness.
Zen's practice is of delusion's loss. To describe a practice of Zen you need only describe the processes resulting in that loss.
Zen describes how to stop empowering our conditioned responses to phenomena that otherwise obscures the unborn, undying and unconditioned experiences of our life from simply illuminating their original natures.
I have yet to see a Buddhist practice that didn't also show me some of this same zen.
how
Cant stay in. My government building is still open. They stagger us...only about 20 people in the building at a time. Get this: per a published Memo, We are responsible for cleaning our own cubes, and the shared printers and work carts. They handed us a jar of Lysol wipes back in May. Im wearing my mask the full 8 hours and cleaning at work as much as at home. …. To cover their own asses, we get a daily e-mail letting us know how many people have tested positive and in what parts of the building they were in and when. Many Federal record centers have closed bec of the numbers...but not us. Im a Tax Examiner and the bills must still go out. * face palm * . ( oh wait, im not supposed to touch my face, damn!)
My Son still has to work too. It's easy to say starting the economy all over is worth it and life is more important than anything....but when you need to eat and are responsible for feeding a family...it's a lot harder to say that. Staying at home is a luxury that a lot of people cant afford. Just something to think about.... Anyway, Hubby and youngest daughter never leave the house....(except for weekly grocery and lotto tickets, hahaha). As soon as Kofi and I walk in the house, someone shouts "Wash your hands!!". He's started carrying a man purse/chest pack with sanitizer, wipes, masks, etc. And my purse is full of it too So...we're doing the best we can...
Vastmind
I'm getting pretty stressed out here. There is now 3 residents infected plus a staff member and a few team members have run off or need to stay home for showing symptoms. I am still only allowed to get picked up to go to work and must self isolate at home.
At work I have a mask, goggles, face shield, gown, gloves and even booties for the infected rooms. At home if I leave the back room I have to wear a mask and stay at least a meter from wife and daughter.
I am so grateful for our practice right now. I'm not sure how I would be coping otherwise.