Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Examples: Monday, today, last week, Mar 26, 3/26/04
Welcome home! Please contact lincoln@icrontic.com if you have any difficulty logging in or using the site. New registrations must be manually approved which may take several days. Can't log in? Try clearing your browser's cookies.

Questions about zen

Hello everyone. I am a new Buddhist and I was introduced to Zen by a member on this forum. I asked how I can determine which actions are skillful versus unskillful and this was the member's response:

"On a practical level, you're making the mistake my old Zen Teacher Young called "checking".

You're trying to check the motives of your actions, and that's an impossible task. I want to do something, but am I acting from selfish or unselfish motivation? If I have a few dollars in the bank, am I being selfish for not giving it to the needy? If I give something to the needy but enjoy it and I'm doing it to get good karma, am I being selfish?

You cannot divide your actions into selfish and nonselfish, or skillful and nonskillful, and always do one and not the other. Motivations in reality are not pure. They are a mix. Likewise the results of your actions, even well meaning, are mixed. You only tie your mind into knots by thinking you can anticipate what you should or should not do this way. That's checking.

As you learn to keep a calm mind and realize you are not your thoughts and not slave to your emotions, you will stop acting out of emotions like anger or jealousy. The meditation and calm mind has to come first. When you practice compassion then acting to hurt others out of selfish desire will stop. The compassion has to come first."

Ever since I read the message above, I've become interested in Zen. However, Zen is very confusing to me. From what I've read, there are no goals in Zen. But if that's true, how come some Zen practitioners follow the five precepts of Buddhism? Isn't striving to follow the five precepts a goal?

I really have a poor understanding of Zen. Is the basis of Zen Buddhism that if one meditates and strives to be mindful all the time they will realize Enlightenment? By the way, meditation and mindfulness sound like goals to me.

If anyone can point me in the direction of learning about Zen, I'd be very grateful.

yagrCinorjerlobster

Comments

  • genkakugenkaku Northampton, Mass. U.S.A. Veteran

    Welcome @followthepath.

    "Zen" is a corruption of the Sanskrit (I believe) word meaning meditation. In Zen, meditation means sit down, erect the spine, shut up, sit still, and focus the mind. In this activity, you are likely to find that the precepts keep themselves. Not all at once, perhaps, but bit by bit. No need to be a "Buddhist." The precepts are simply what makes best sense.

    Or maybe not. Sit down, focus the mind and find out. Goal or no goal ... find out.

    lobsterWalkerCinorjer
  • lobsterlobster Crusty Veteran

    @followthepath said:
    By the way, meditation and mindfulness sound like goals to me.

    If anyone can point me in the direction of learning about Zen, I'd be very grateful.

    Did you require a picture of a cushion? :p Oooh I iz so zen :pleased:

    Walkerkarasti
  • WalkerWalker Veteran Veteran

    Meditation and mindfulness are tools, as I understand them. Not goals unto themselves. They are examples of the finger pointing at the moon.

    Shoshinherberto
  • DairyLamaDairyLama Veteran Veteran

    @genkaku said:> "Zen" is a corruption of the Sanskrit (I believe) word meaning meditation.

    Yes, dhyana became Chan which became Zen.

  • RuddyDuck9RuddyDuck9 MD, USA Veteran

    @followthepath Thank you for posting this. I'm always a bit scared to ask questions like this one, but I very sincerely appreciate your courage. I have learned much from this thread, as well.

    followthepath
  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    edited June 2016

    @RuddyDuck9 it pains me to know you're a 'bit scared of asking questions like this one' because I know we try to convey benign feelings and welcome even the most basic questions, which I have to say, get asked over and over again, with gay abandon.... and we always answer.

    Please never be afraid of asking anything here. There are many "helping hands" all willing to offer support, responses and assistance for everything you may need....

    I will immediately say I closed a thread by @Benjamin, a newbie, who asked about favourite reading matter, but that was because a long thread already exists and is "stickied" and I held that most, if not all of the responses would merely have been repeating the same information as in the linked thread I offered.... It wasn't done through any impatience, exasperation or annoyance....At all.

    His question was strictly specific; most new members have questions pertaining to matters relating to their own experiences, and are therefore meritorious of attention and response... we are always ready to help.

  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator

    Number 1 is too avant garde and noisy for my liking.
    2, when I say so.
    Sadly, I'm old enough to answer number 3.... The Liver Birds...
    4 - I honestly think nobody knows an answer to that one....

    RuddyDuck9herberto
  • lobsterlobster Crusty Veteran

    Thanks @federica

    Further commentary:

    1. Who let the dogs out?

    As the dogs were never in
    Who can let them out?
    Who? Who?

    1. When is enough enough?

    Say when?
    Enough?
    Enough said.

    Normal service is now resumed ...

    herbertokarasti
  • @lobster said:
    Favourite dumb koans:

    1. Who let the dogs out?
    2. When is enough enough?
    3. "You dancing?", "You asking?", "I'm asking!", "I'm dancing!"
    4. Trump!
    1. Arf!
    2. The wind in the trees.
    3. You're not dancing.
    4. For some things even Zen Masters have no answer.
    Swarooplobster
  • zenffzenff Veteran

    Why bother to practice Zen, if at the heart of the matter there’s nothing to gain?
    That’s not a bad question at all.

    I think there’s no progress in covering the problem up as a mysterious koan or in ignoring it and hoping it will go away after enough years of serious practice.
    It won’t. It’s simply a very good question.
    It is better to be ruthlessly clear about that.
    imho

    CinorjerlobsterVastmind
  • lobsterlobster Crusty Veteran

    @followthepath said:
    I really have a poor understanding of Zen.

    Cool. Nothing worse than a rich understanding of Zen.
    In other words, like a dervish, belong to the poor.

    The 'oi dunno' mind is not a pose but a constant beginning, rather than 'progress'.

    If you've lost focus, just sit down and be still. Take the idea and rock it to and fro. Keep some of it and throw some away, and it will renew itself. You need do no more. Clarissa Pinkola Estes

    CinorjerFosdickVastmind
  • seeker242seeker242 Zen Florida, USA Veteran

    @zenff said:
    Why bother to practice Zen, if at the heart of the matter there’s nothing to gain?

    To stop trying to gain something. :)

  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator

    ...Or to stop trying to stop trying....

  • seeker242seeker242 Zen Florida, USA Veteran

    Or, to stop trying, to stop trying to stop trying!

  • federicafederica Seeker of the clear blue sky... Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool, than to speak out and remove all doubt Moderator
    edited June 2016

    Or to....

    .....I forget what we're remembering......

    How very 'Zen'...!

    seeker242RuddyDuck9
  • DairyLamaDairyLama Veteran Veteran

    Oi dunno. :p

  • ShoshinShoshin No one in particular Nowhere Special Veteran

    If anyone can point me in the direction of learning about Zen, I'd be very grateful.

    I guess one could say Zen is just being .....whatever.....whenever...however....wherever the dice falls so be 'it' ....

    This short intro by Shunryu Suzuki might be of some help...

  • row37row37 st pete, fl Explorer

    I agree, Zen is VERY confusing to read about. It's pretty awful actually, and yet it is so beautifully simple (yet difficult) to practice. My advice is to forget all the nonsense you may have read, it will usually just make you more confused. Remember, Zen is a teaching outside the Buddhist scriptures. You can't get it from reading, it has to be through practice.

    So how do you practice it? The best way is to sit in meditation for 20 minutes in the morning, 20 minutes in the evening, and find a good Zen center if you can in your city. The rest will fall into place....eventually. It's a lifelong path. Returning to your breath is always wise in annoying or stressful situations. And try to live a compassionate life, especially in regards to eating poor, tortured and murdered sentient beings. Respect the earth and yourself despite your flaws. And if you do find a clear and concise book, read it, but it is in the practice of each and every moment that the truth is revealed to us. Hard to get there when we're running around in our heads 24/7, or so full of what we have read and our own opinions that there is no room for the truth.

    lobsterfollowthepathRuddyDuck9
Sign In or Register to comment.