I was visiting old bookmarks, and I came across this on Lions Roar:
https://www.lionsroar.com/buddhisms-five-remembrances-are-wake-up-calls-for-us-all/
The lead-in of the story is that so many people ask you, can you tell me what Buddhism is about? Some people start talking about the Buddha, some people about suffering, others about the Three Seals of the Buddha’s teaching. Koun Franz, the articles author, talks about the Five Remembrances, which are these…
I am of the nature to grow old. There is no way to escape growing old.
I am of the nature to have ill health. There is no way to escape having ill health.
I am of the nature to die. There is no way to escape death.
All that is dear to me and everyone I love are of the nature to change. There is no way to escape being separated from them.
My actions are my only true belongings. I cannot escape the consequences of my actions. My actions are the ground upon which I stand.
Jeroen
I found some useful reminders about the awareness of breath in the essay, that was good. At the same time, I feel it is missing a certain poetry… the breath is one of the glories of the body, and to communicate the beauty of it needs a poetic quality. Maybe a tip for next time? 🙏
Jeroen
Hello, dear friends on the Path;
It's been a spell since I've been on but we've shared a lot over the years and there is a lot of insight on this site. Hope everybody is doing alright. This is a bit longer so don't feel bad if it's one of those tldr deals.
In September, I started a 3-5 year Dharma Teachers course which will see me ordained as a Zen Buddhist Priest. After that, I'll add Chaplaincy. I've taken the Five Mindfulness Trainings in the Plum Village Tradition and the Bodhisattva Precepts with my current Zen Tradition and this feels like the natural next step.
As part of said course there are a few essays I have to write. I just finished one on the Awareness of Breathing and I just wanted to share it here in case it helps anyone or in case anyone has any feedback. Not to worry, I've already handed it in so I can't edit any more.
Was just thinking of you guys is all.
Breathing in, I am beginning to type. Breathing out, I am going to enjoy writing this essay. Within, I use the guidance from the Anapanasati Sutta along with the Venerable Thich Nhat Hanh's commentary in the book, “Breathe… You are Alive” as well as what I
have learned from my teacher the Venerable
Bhikkuni Thich nu Tinh Quang.
Breathing meditation is a practice recommended by the Buddha to ground us in the present moment and help us to awaken. The breath happens whether we think about it or not. Whether we notice it or not. However, when we do notice it and pay attention to
it, we can be more easily aware of everything else.
I was lucky to have attended a Vipassana
Meditation course and the first of seven weeks was centered around the Mindfulness of Breathing. I learned that there is so much more to breathing meditation than solely the breath, however, it can be our natural anchor because it is always with us which means we can use it at any time to remind and help us to be more aware and bring us back to the present moment. When we bring conscious
attention to the breath, a whole world of awareness opens up.
When we catch ourselves getting carried away by thought we can then go back to the breath. Catching ourselves making distracting storylines is the trick. Once we notice, we have already broken the spell and the more we notice, the easier it gets to notice.
Although it may seem repetitive, returning to the breath again and again gradually develops
concentration and helps us let go of the incessant need to identify with the thought stream.
Because we often overlook the natural rhythm and flow of the breath, we don’t see how it can act as a tether between body and mind and thus, the present moment. Through the awareness of breathing, we can be more focused and thus more aware of the subtle changes in our body, mind and the environment we are not separate from.
Our monkey mind wants to swing from branch to branch, from thought to thought. Thoughts arise depending on conditions, just like everything else, and in turn, they condition what follows. When we see we are going off on a tangent, just this realization is enough to snap out of it and go back to the breath. We can train our monkey.
When we use the words “breathing in, I am aware of (whatever we happen to be doing or noticing)” it leaves no alternate branches to swing to. There is no room for worries about yesterday or tomorrow and so it steers the monkey into an ideal direction. It takes our current conditioning into our own hands.
Thich Nhat Hanh said that during walking
meditation, when we are inside we can take a
breath with every step and when we are outside with others around us we can take two or even three steps with every breath. In, in, in... Out, out, out... Long, long, long... Short, short, short. In this way, we are using the breath as a bridge to call attention to the walking. Then, like the raft on the far shore, we can abandon the words when they become
automatic or second nature and there is just the breath. We are not trying to control the breath, only noticing and paying attention to the quality.
For the Awareness of Breath in the Body Meditation, it is usually recommended we start at the top of the head and slowly work our way down to the feet. Before I started writing this paper, that is how I always did it. Lately, however, I’ve experimented with starting at the lungs and radiating awareness
outward. It has been helping me to stay rooted in the function of the breath itself while strengthening my concentration and, in turn, my compassion. It is also helping me write this essay from my own perspective.
I like to start with my lungs and move out from there. Every part of the body is nourished by the breath and this is obviously especially true for the lungs. Breathing feeds our cells oxygen, helping to build energy. Cellular respiration is our cells using oxygen to convert food to energy. Red blood cells armed with the hemoglobin protein carry oxygen to tissues and organs and carry the carbon dioxide waste away to be exhaled. This gas exchange happens during the circulation between the lungs and the heart which is why I start the awareness of body with the lungs, radiate awareness from there and end with the heart. After scanning the lungs, I move
outward to the stomach and other organs, then my pelvic area. Just looking for anything that needs attention. Any pains, tiredness, itchiness… Anything, really. I acknowledge it and give a compassionate and mindful hug. From there I move to the arms, legs, hands and feet. Then it’s up to the face, mouth, nose, ears, eyes and then the brain. We have an electrical spark in both the brain and the heart so next I go to the heart which figuratively completes the respiratory cycle between inhalation and exhalation.
After going through the various parts of the body, I can then move into the awareness of breath in feelings. With mindful breathing, I can begin to notice whether the sensations in the body and/or mind are pleasant, unpleasant or neutral. This noticing is done without judgement and without adding a storyline. If I feel warmth, tiredness or even
joy, I simply label it as positive, negative or
indifferent and let it go. Observing feelings in this way without judgement, and the reaction that follows closely behind, can bring clarity and allow the feeling to go as it came without attaching to it or the need to react to it. It can just pass through like a cloud in the sky.
This kind of gentle, non-reactive awareness
reinforces the old adage that says “while pain is inevitable, suffering is optional”. In the Buddha’s teaching on the two arrows, the first arrow represents the unavoidable pain that life brings and the second arrow is the one we wound ourselves with through judgements and storylines. With mindful breathing and awareness of feelings, we learn not to shoot that second arrow. We can choose compassion instead.
Breathing in, I am aware of the seed of anxiety being watered. Breathing out, I water the seed of compassion to sprout and be with the anxiety. Breathing in, a light shines on anxiety. Breathing out, anxiety is transformed to well-being.
Sometimes a feeling is very strong. We might attach to it very quickly and it can become a mental formation before we realize it’s happening. Thoughts and feelings arise all the time in our experience and once we begin to cling to them or weave a story around them, they become mental formations.
The conditions arise for anger to manifest and it does. This is just an emotional reaction. Once we begin to think “I’m always doing this” or “Nobody gets me” we start creating a story and now a momentary feeling gains weight and becomes a mental formation and can condition our future experience and interactions. In this way a small reaction can become a big problem and cause a lot of suffering.
Mindfulness of breathing allows us to witness this process as it unfolds. With the breath as our anchor, we can observe the formation arising without being swept away. Without identifying with it. Breathing in, we recognize it; breathing out, we release the need to form a self. In this way, the breath gives us the
spaciousness to let go.
Thich Nhat Hanh also reminds us that it is helpful to be grateful for what we are not suffering. For example, if we have a headache, it is easy to attend to it because of the constant reminder. But when we don’t have a headache, we don’t often think to be grateful for the headache not manifesting.
When we no longer identify with mental formations, we free ourselves to notice not only what hurts, but also what doesn’t. The absence of pain is often invisible. With mindfulness, it becomes a blessing.
When we consciously breathe, we are inviting
ourselves to be present. We are becoming attuned to the sensations in our body, the thoughts that come and go and the emotions that follows shortly after. We are not trying to force anything to change, we are just here to observe. We are nurturing a sense of spaciousness within ourselves, allowing
thoughts and feelings to come and go without
resistance. Change happens gracefully here, with no more effort than it takes to breathe.
In my practice, I find that beginning the day with mindful breathing sets a tone of calm and gratitude. No matter what challenges arise, the breath is always available as a refuge. This hits home daily and is only getting more profound even with the writing of this essay. I can feel the usual patterns of thought and worry being left behind as I cultivate a
deeper connection with myself in, and as, the
world.
Breathing in, I recognize the gift of being alive.
Breathing out, I smile to the world within and around me.
-Quang Ksanti
I’ve noticed that a lot of the internet news and discussion scene seems to be about generating worry in readers. It’s a clickbaiting strategy — if you can make someone worried they are likely to dig deeper. I thought the video on Apple’s examination of AI to be quite thorough. They found that what the reasoning models were doing was more akin to pattern matching, than to true reasoning, and that reasoning performance dropped off steeply beyond about seven or ten logical steps.
Apple’s researchers attributed this to there being numerous examples on the internet of reasoning chains with that kind of length, and very few of longer chains. Even when given the algorithm for solving a puzzle in clear language, the models didn’t follow the steps. It seems that understanding and reason were not there.
So do we need a technology beyond LLMs to truly solve these issues? I think it is likely. I still think these problems are likely to be resolved, and we will have something resembling general AI in the next decade, things are moving rapidly at the moment.
Jeroen
@lobster said:
We can indeed protect ourselves by:
Pausing. Wait after a 'life threatening' call from bank, relative, government etc
Scammers using AI are slower than you BUT try to rush you. This is one of the benefits of meditative calm.Use better software and encourage your circle to use
Use your gut feeling, experience and don't be a target
https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/section/advice-guidance/you-your-family
Good advice, it gets harder as people get older and the technology gets unfamiliar to them and cognitive capacity declines. My mother got half scammed once, they got her to respond and do a thing or two, thankfully she caught on and stopped.
The difficulties with our transition to an AI future goes well beyond that. How do people, and society as a whole protect themselves from being economically useless? Being exploited is one thing, but what happens to people when they no longer serve a purpose to the system?
person
It’s especially going to affect people in so called “knowledge economies”, where most of the work being done is no longer manual labour. An economy like Ethiopia is not going to come out vastly different from what it is now.
But it will affect the concentration of wealth. All kinds of things will suddenly become cheaper to produce, like journalism, books, computer code, websites, apps, art and design, videos… the methods of production of these will suddenly become democratised, allowing people with very little means to produce pet projects and self publish them.
Jeroen
In fact, “Capital in the Age of AI” poses interesting questions. If anyone will be able to hire a cloud AI agent to do genius-level work for them for just a few dollars an hour, this will have a huge influence on the production of anything mental. Instead of paying thousands of dollars to hire actual labour, you can get nearly anything you want done for cheap.
Jeroen
I liked this one.
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/how-to-deal-with-difficult-emotions-difficult-feedback/id1087147821?i=1000703709070
Diane Musho Hamilton, author and Zen teacher. She talks about something akin to spiritual bypassing. My take is something along the lines of devoted spiritual seekers over the centuries have removed themselves from society to pursue waking up, and necessarily so to reach such refined states. Living in the world involves dealing with other people and requires some sort of emotional maturity to do skillfully. I think I've very unconsciously made some efforts in that direction as I abandoned the idea of traditional renunciation, but maybe now that I've heard it framed in this manner can feel comfortable making more conscious efforts.
I think also what spoke to me is the way it was presented in this discussion at least, I found it fairly digestible. I'm much more practical and stoic than idealistic and sentimental, and I feel like much of emotional work gets framed in the latter more than the former manner.
person
One thing I hear is that the experience of ayahuasca has brought many who drink it to believe in a spirit world, and my own experience of occasional visions has inclined me likewise. So there are certain correspondences between those who have walked this path and myself.
Our modern world has been stripped of its visionary influences, its mythological components, by science and the tendency to investigate and disassemble. Those of us who do still have those experiences are not helped by modern mental health institutions, which encourage us to see these as hallucinations only and stick to a medical and materialist view of the world.
I find in the indigenous traditions a different wisdom, a rich tapestry of story and meaning linked to a much older world, where there were bards and storytellers and shamans and elders. These kinds of people are not found so much anymore in modern cities.
Jeroen